This Matter of Musical Leadership

Not long ago a young friend of mine was placed in charge of the music activities of one of our training schools. Desirous of being of some help to him, I wrote him a letter. And believing it may prove helpful to others in similar places of opportunity, I give here that part of the letter referring to musical leader­ship:

By CARLYLE B. HAYNES, President, Michigan Conference

Not long ago a young friend of mine was placed in charge of the music activities of one of our training schools. Desirous of being of some help to him, I wrote him a letter. And believing it may prove helpful to others in similar places of opportunity, I give here that part of the letter referring to musical leader­ship:

"It occurs to me that in the opportunities which will now present themselves to you, you have a great opportunity to demonstrate that musical leaders can be developed in this de­nomination who are quiet, simple, and un­affected, and who have but one thing in mind in all their leading,--to glorify God instead of glorifying self. Some of us who have been a long time in the evangelistic work of this denomination have come to fear that there is little possibility of Seventh-day Adventists' ever seeing that kind of music leader in their work.

"My own experience, I suppose, has been un­fortunate. So far as my experience extends, we have not had any outstanding music leaders whose sole purpose has seemed to be to glorify God. We have had the other kind to such a de­gree that most of us who love music and love the cause of God have been so distressed that we have about given up hope that music can ever come into its own in connection with the preach­ing of this message. The circus-performer type of leader seems to have crowded all others off our platforms.

"I have been present on more than one occa­sion and heard you protest that music is not appreciated among Seventh-day Adventist evan­

have pointed out that it is not given the place it deserves in connection with our public meetings. Indeed, if I remember correctly, you have done some rather earnest missionary work with me on several occasions because I did not pay more attention to the importance of music.

"Let me say to you now that what you look upon, in me and in many others, as failure to appreciate music, is not at all a lack of appre­ciation. It is an attitude which is due, rather, to the fact that we are surfeited with the kind of music which we have observed in connection with our efforts, accompanied, as much of it has been, by foolishness and outright violation of all the music standards of this cause.

"I love music. I believe it can be made a great power for good in this cause. I cannot help observing, however, that it is constantly prostituted to the glory of the human instead of being used to glorify the divine. I have come to the place, along with many others, where if I cannot have music that glorifies God, then I will endeavor to get along without music.

"It is because of this that I am wondering whether you may not be induced to see that now, in a new field, surrounded by new people, you have an unparalleled opportunity for work­ing out a change and providing a demonstra­tion before it is forever too late for some of us. Do you not want to show that music really can be led in an unaffected, yet dignified and im­pressive way without one thought of self, and with but one thought in mind, that of worship?

"I would have you eliminate all parade, all showing off, all display of ability, and in the place of these, endeavor to get every person's mind on the glory of worshiping God in this most beautiful way.

"Any evidence of pride on the part of the leader will be copied by his chorus. If the leader shows off, the chorus will show off. If the leader manifests a tendency to display his ability, the singers will want to display their abilities, too. What the leader is, the singers are going to be. Every demonstration of self-glorification on the part of the leader will lead to a demonstration of self-glorification on the part of the singers. If the leader's central thought is on worship, and all his actions cor­respond with that thought, then those who sing under him will have as their central thought the worship of God. If the leader approaches his task with a sense of its sacredness and is impressed with the opportunity of worshiping God in the sweetest and most profitable way that God can be worshiped, then the singers will approach their task in the same way. Such a leader will be a true leader. The other kind are only performers, and not true leaders at all.

"If you will let your mind pass over the memories of the great musicians, some of whom you have been privileged to hear, you will not fail to recall that the ones who made the great­est impression upon you were those who were the simplest and the most unaffected. Do you recall Jascha Heifetz as he stood there on the platform of Carnegie Hall, and without any affectation, without a false movement, without any showing off, or swaying, or moving about of any kind, just played? Do you recall the effect it had upon us as we sat there listening? There was the world's master of the violin! But there was no solitary evidence that he was thinking of anything in the world but the music. It was clear that he was not wanting anyone who heard him to think of anything but the music. I do not doubt that that is just the reason why he is the world's master of the violin. He lost sight of self and was absorbed in the music.

"Think of Walter Damrosch, without ex­aggerated movement of any kind for forty years in all his leading! Think of Paderewski, so wholly absorbed in his music that he did not seem to realize there was anybody within a thousand miles of him.

"I wish you might have had the opportunity, as I have had many times, of seeing Charles M. Alexander as he led the great throngs that waited on the ministry of J. Wilbur Chapman and R. A. Torrey. He was all aflame with the desire to lift men, on the wings of song, into the presence of God, and did not seek glory for him­self. There were no circus antics, no running about over the platform, no rushing toward a group of singers and attempting to pull music out of their throats. His was just a quiet, impressive dignity, an altogether Christian demonstration of musical leadership.

"Now, dear friend, these men and others like them have been able to pass beyond the things of earth that hold some of our other leaders to their foolish antics, because they became ab­sorbed in their task until it was the greatest thing in all the world. If men outside of this cause do this, do we not have an even greater incentive? We can become absorbed in music just as they do, but with us it must always be a medium to lead us to something else, a means to an end. We should become absorbed in music because it glorifies our Maker. Sacred music is worship. When music is used in con­nection with religious services for any other purpose than worship, the man who so uses it is repeating what Nadab and Abihu did—offer­ing strange fire before God. Such men have no place in our evangelistic services.

"Well, perhaps this is enough. I have no doubt you will be able to gather the general thought. I should like to see you set yourself to eliminate from your leadership every ele­ment of self, and to discover the great possi­bilities of restoring music in this cause to the place from which it has fallen and to which it will never rise again unless we can develop such leaders as I have described."

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

By CARLYLE B. HAYNES, President, Michigan Conference

April 1937

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Principles, Problems, and Policies No. 2

Countering the questioning of authority and the breaking down of responsibility.

Preaching Our Distinctive Message* No. 1

Why is it that so many of our evangelists wait so long to proclaim the third angel's message?

Motion Pictures in Evangelism

The showing of harmful pictures should not close our eyes to turn the minds of people toward good pictures that will be a blessing and not a curse.

"Before Whom Three Fell" Daniel 7:20

Considering the two possible meanings of the expression occurring in Daniel 7:20.

Avoid Extremes

The enemy of our souls would gladly lead us to take extreme positions. It does not matter much to him in which direction we go, whether to the right or to the left, if only we become extreme in the position which we take.

Qualifications for True Leadership No. 1

A leader in any capacity in the cause of God is a watchman, and his office carries with it most solemn responsibility.

My First Year as an Intern

Many things awaited me, of which I was unaware that day in the union president's office when I accepted a Bible worker's intern­ship.

The Challenge of Islam

The presentation of the gospel message to Moslems constitutes one of the greatest problems confronting the Christian missionary today.

Editorial Keynotes

From the editor's desk.

The Alcohol Problem No. 4

Alcohol as a narcotic.

Gratifying Results in the South

To those who are waiting for that soon-coming day when truth shall triumph glo­riously, there is nothing more cheering than news of fresh victories won on the battle front.

The Conflict of the Ages Series No. 4

Part four of our series on Mrs. White's writings.

Meaning of "Breath" and "Soul"

In 1 Kings 17:17, 22, we find the expressions, "There was no breath left in him," and "The soul of the child came into him again, and he revived." Kindly give an effectual explanation for believers in immortality, and also give the Hebrew meaning of "breath" and "soul." Are they identical words?

Valuable Quotations

Verified extracts from current literature.

Editorial Postscripts

From the Ministry back page!

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated


Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)