Repentance or Penance

Is there any ground in the original Greek for the use of "penance" or "do penance" in the Douay Bible in place of "repentance" and "repent" in the King James?

W. E. HOWELL. [Theological Seminary]

Is there any ground in the original Greek for the use of "penance" or "do penance" in the Douay Bible in place of "repentance" and "repent" in the King James?

The word penance is really an older form of the word penitence, and do penance an older form of do penitence or repent. Wyc­liffe's translation, more than two hundred years before King James, reads: "And I seye to you, so joye schal be in heuene on o synful man doinge penaunce more than on nynty and nyne juste that han no nede to penaunce." Luke 15 :7. The term comes from the Latin paenitet, meaning cause to regret or to feel sorrow. But it is frequently used in a sense as derived from poena or punio, punishment or punish.

The older meaning of penance was to do something, to show sorrow for wrong doing, and grew easily into the meaning of doing something to atone for sin—self-infliction or punishment in expiation. for sin. Thus it came to be righteousness by works. In the Greek and Roman Catholic Churches, as also in some heathen religions, confession is made to a priest. The priest prescribes the punish­ment, the penitent undergoes the punishment or inflicts it on himself,—sometimes over a long period of time,—returns to the priest for absolution, and then goes free from his sin.

Looking at the original Greek, one finds both the verb geraPaco (nietanoeo) and the noun /heravovcra (inetanoesis) meaning a change of mind—the true meaning of re­pentance in relation to sin, and synonymous with change of heart. When this is experi­enced, a change in deeds and life follows as a natural fruitage.

So while repent means to change over the mind, penance (verb) or do penance may mean "pass over the pence," or to do some­thing worthy of absolution. Seldon, in his "Table Talk," says; "Penance is only the punishment inflicted, not penitence, which is the right word." And quoting from Prior:

"Better not do the deed than weep it done, 

No penance can absolve our guilty frame."

Keats, the poet, says:

"His was harsh penance on St. Agnes' Eve:

Another way he went, and soon among

Rough ashes sat he for his soul's reprieve."

An ecclesiastical definition in the Century Dictionary declares penance to be:

"Sorrow for sin shown by outward acts under au­thority and regulation of the church; contrition man­ifested by confession and satisfaction and entitling to absolution; hence, absolution ensuing upon con­trition and confession with satisfaction or purpose of satisfaction. Absolution has been given on these terms since primitive times in the church, and this ancient institution was afterward formally recog­nized as a sacrament by the Roman Catholic, the Greek, and other churches. The sacrament of pen­ance includes four parts: contrition, confession, satisfaction, and absolution. It is required that there should be a genuine and a supernatural con­trition for the sin committed; that is, a sorrow produced by the influence of the Holy Spirit, coupled with a firm purpose of amendment; that the sin should be confessed fully and unreservedly to a priest; and that satisfaction be made for it by a voluntary submission to such penalty or discipline as the priest may require and by restitution to per­sons wronged ; and absolution can be granted only on these conditions. It can be administered by no one who has not received priest's orders. Every member of the Roman Catholic Church is obliged at least once a year to confess to his parish priest and to do penance under his direction ; he cannot partake of communion without previous absolution, but is not either before confession or during his penitential discipline regarded as under ecclesiastical censure, which is inflicted on the contumacious only."

The reader may have noted President Roosevelt's recent use of the word "contuma­cious" in his ultimatum to Arthur E. Morgan, chairman of the TVA, who would not do the commanded penance of resigning and was therefore adjudged contumacious.

W. E. HOWELL. [Theological Seminary]

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

W. E. HOWELL. [Theological Seminary]

November 1938

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

My Books are My Wealth

All our contributory reading should be designed to strengthen us in faith and experience, that we may be greater men of God, and more efficient ministers of His word.

Challenge of Daybreak in Islam—No. I

A look at three great facts relating to the challenge of Islam to Christianity.

Essentials for Success in God's World

In the heart of every true worker there is an earnest desire and a laudable ambition to be a success in the work to which he has been assigned. As workers we do well fre­quently to study just what constitutes essen­tials for success in the work of God.

Meeting the Scientific Attitude

For many people, science has not simply disproved but also displaced God

Neat Bible Worker Uniform*

The sole purpose of an evangelistic cam­paign is to save souls. To this end, every detail should be planned with utmost care, in order that all essentials may be provided for and that the work of the campaign may pro­gress with ease

Potency of Sacred Song

In the lives of Christians the church serv­ice is an important factor, and it is logical that music have a most important part in their worship.

Utilizing Twentieth-Century Facilities

The twentieth century—just three words, but what rivers of swift-flowing thought they immediately conjure up. Conspicu­ously outstanding in the midst of all these latter-day streams flow the swollen waters of that powerful, captivating, breath-taking tor­rent—that mighty river, scientific modern advantages.

Bible-Centered Preaching

Men need life; therefore they need the Book of life—the Bible.

Effective Evangelistic Advertising

Effective advertising for an evangelis­tic effort may be considered under five heads:(1) Subject title;(2)The personal invitation;(3)The newspaper;(4)The window card;and(5)The billboard.

Speculation and the Ministry

There are two lessons which the Christian worker must learn when he turns his back upon the world to follow "righteousness, godli­ness, faith, love, patience, meekness"—the lessons of godliness and contentment.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - SermonView - Medium Rect (300x250)

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)