Problems of Daniel 1

Problems of Daniel 1 (Concluded)

In the article last month on the problems of A the I and their solution, five problems were stipulated, and we dealt with three, showing that they were no problem at all. We come now to problems 4 and 5, and their explanation.

By E. R. THIELE, Instructor in Religion, Emmanuel Missionary College

In the article last month on the problems of A the I and their solution, five problems were stipulated, and we dealt with three, showing that they were no problem at all. We come now to problems 4 and 5, and their explanation.

4. The fourth argument urged against Daniel i a is that it is in contradiction to all other contemporaneous accounts. But there are no other contemporary Babylonian, Pal­estinian, or Egyptian records in existence for this particular period ; so no contradiction to such records is possible. The Bible is not only our best source, but practically our only source, for the reconstruction of the history of this region during this period. And there is nothing in the Bible that contradicts Daniel 1:1. But if there is no contemporary material from this time that bears on this question, there is available an important statement from Josephus which he gives as a direct quotation from Berosus. This statement is as follows:

 "When Nabolassar [Nabopolassar], father of Nab­uchodonosor [Nebuchadnezzar], heard that the gov­ernor whom he had set over Egypt, and over the parts of Celesyria and Phoenicia, had revolted from him, he was not able to bear it any longer ; but com­mitting certain parts of his army to his son Nabu­chodonosor, who was then but young, he sent him against the rebel: Nabuchodonosor joined battle with him, and conquered him, and reduced the country under his dominion again. Now it so fell out that his father Nabolassar fell into distemper at this time, and died in the city of Babylon, after he had reigned twenty-nine years,

"But as he understood, in a little time, that his father Nabolassar was deadh he set the affairs of Egypt and the other countries in order, and com­mitted the captives he had taken from the Jews, and Phoenicians, and Syrians, and of the nations belong­ing to Egypt, to some of his friends, that they might conduct that part of the forces that had on heavy armor, with the rest of his baggage, to Babylonia ; while he went in haste, having but a few with him, over the desert to Babylon; whither, when he was come, he found the public affairs had been managed by the Chaldeans, and that the principal person among them had preserved the kingdom for him. Accord­ingly, he now entirely obtained all his father's do­minions. He then came, and ordered the captives to be placed as colonies in the most proper places of Babylonia ; but for himself, he adorned the temple of Belus, and the other temples, after an elegant manner, out of the spoils he had taken in this war."—"Flavius Josephus Against Apion," I :19.

This quotation from Berosus, as preserved by Josephus, is of course not a contemporary, but a late, account. It is, however, of value. The following details should be noted :

a. Celesyria, Phoenicia, etc., were already under Babylonian control during the reign of Nabopolassar, father of Nebuchadnezzar.

b. A revolt took place in these regions against Babylon.

c. Nabolassar sent his son Nebuchadnezzar with an army to quell this revolt.

d. While on this expedition, Nebuchadnezzar heard of his father's death. 

e. Nebuchadnezzar committed his Jewish and Phoenician captives to a friend, and hurried back to Babylon to take the throne.

f. The throne secured, Nebuchadnezzar placed the captives in colonies in Babylon.

g. Nebuchadnezzar adorned his temples with the spoils taken in the war.

It will be seen that there are in this account some remarkable confirmatory details to the account of Daniel t. Of particular importance are the mention of Nebuchadnezzar's expedi­tion to the west during the year when he ascended the throne (which would be the third year of Jehoiakim, as stated in Daniel i :t), the seizure of Jewish captives and their transport to Babylon, and the adornment of Babylonian temples with loot taken in the western war.

Thus we find that there is no truth in the statement that Daniel 1:1 is in contradiction to all other contemporaneous accounts, and that the only Babylonian account of this event still preserved, which dates from a few centuries later, confirms the account of this text to a remarkable degree.

5. In answer to problem five, that Daniel could not have completed three years' training in Babylon by the second year of Nebuchad­nezzar, it need only be stated that any supposed difficulty vanishes when the accession-year principle and the inclusive system of reckoning then in use are taken into consideration. Daniel was taken captive during the accession year of Nebuchadnezzar and began his period of train­ing that year. This accounts for the first year. His second year of training came during Nebu­chadnezzar's first year, and his third year during Nebuchadnezzar's second year. His training completed, it would thus be altogether possible for Daniel to be included among the wise men by Nebuchadnezzar's second year.

It will thus be seen that the facts recorded in Daniel 1 stand unimpugned when faced in the light of the systein of chronology then em­ployed in Judea and Babylon, and when com­pared with the best historical testimony avail­able from that time.

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

By E. R. THIELE, Instructor in Religion, Emmanuel Missionary College

September 1941

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Direct Evangelism Our Primary Task

The work for which we have been called into existence is to proclaim in all the world God's message for this time, and "to make ready a people prepared for the Lord."

Adaptability Under War Conditions

Why we need to be flexible in changing times.

Evangelism Where There are No Churches

At times we hear discussions that so emphasize the value of the laity in the preparation and work during evange­listic efforts, that some might well conclude that it would be almost impossible to conduct a successful effort where there is not already a church.

Lay Evangelism and Bible Studies

How local pastors and lay members can equip themselves for soul-winning work.

The Canons of Sacred Music

What are the canons, or laws, of sacred music which should govern our choice of sacred music ?

Prophetic Guidance in Early Days

The final article in our series of our look at the influence of the spirit of Prophecy in 1844-1855 look at the development of later attitudes toward the prophetic gift.

What is the Chistian's Best Strategy?

How best do we engage with evolution?

Editorial Keynotes

From the Editor's desk.

A Call for Educational Evangelism

Recognizing the three phases of evangelism.

Safeguards and Responsibilities

A Christian character is the best se­curity to be obtained in the safeguard­ing of money and other values. Hon­esty, sincerity, integrity, and faithfulness in private relations and in public duties, are the qualities which give assurance of moral re­sponsibility.

A Spiritual Lesson from Physiology

There is a phenomenon exhibited by some of the outstanding tissues of the body which demonstrates the "all-or-none law."

Simplifications of Nursing Arts--No. 1

It s the purpose of this article to review simplifications of procedure which may be taught parallel with Nursing Arts, and which may be used while doing nursing in the home.

The Missionary Doctor's Consultant

The challenging and difficult situations of an overseas physician.

The Medical Work in Evangelism

Presentation at a Bible workers' meeting, Gen­eral Conference, San Francisco.

Order of Progressive Bible Studies

Is there a best order for giving bible studies to those unacquainted with our faith?

Dealing With Feuds and Factions

It sometimes happens that feuds and factions spring up in churches, greatly hindering the progress of the work, and turning souls from the church in discouragement and disgust.

Capitalize the Pastor's Study

Let us think of the pastor's study, or office, not only as a medium for contact with church members, but also as an agency toward more efficient work for the pastor in his min­istry.

Editorial Postscripts

From the Ministry back page.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)