Preaching on Punishment for Sin

To accept the doctrine of eternal torment is to repudiate the gospel. One cannot consistently believe in both.

Bv Louis F. CUNNINGHAM, Licensed Minister, Chesapeake Conference

In meeting any false doctrine one should base the initial discussion on those points on which we agree. The more numerous and the more fundamental these agreements are, the more likely we are to convince those in error on other points. No one likes to admit that he is altogether wrong about anything. But if he can be shown that some of his conclusions are de­structive to the most sacred and basic princi­ples of his own faith, he may be more ready to reconsider and to accept the truth.

Nothing is more fundamental than the gos­pel of our Lord Jesus. No better foundation can be laid for any doctrine than this. And no other emphasis should ever take its place, for souls must be converted, and not merely con­vinced on technicalities. We need never divorce the justice of God from His mercy. This is the weakest link of the "eternal torment" theory, as taught by its adherents. For this very rea­son we should all the more determine to make our teaching of the subject an inseparable part of the gospel.

To accept the doctrine of eternal torment is to repudiate the gospel. One cannot consistently believe in both. In the gospel the Lord Jesus Christ is set forth as man's sin-bearer, his sub­stitute. "The Lord bath laid on Him the iniq­uity of us all." Isa. 53 :6. In accepting our guilt, He received our condemnation. This penalty He must pay in full before we may go free. For Him to do less than that would be to fail altogether. Most Christians will agree on this.

From this point of mutual and fundamental agreement we may readily decide whether the wages of sin is death, or never-ending torment. For whatever the penalty is, that is the price Jesus must pay in our stead. We know God provided "that He by the grace of God should taste death for every man." Heb. 2 :9. If death, then, is the penalty, the debt is paid in full, and we are redeemed.

But what about the doctrine of eternal tor­ment? How does that fit into the plan of re­demption? There is no change in the plan. It still requires that the Sin Bearer satisfy the demands of divine justice. Here is the crucial point. If the punishment for sin is unending torture, either the Lord Jesus is doomed to suf­fer that horrible penalty, or the whole family of earth is hopelessly lost. It is clear from this that those who would condemn man to eternal torment condemn Christ to the same, "for He hath made Him to be sin for us." 2 Cor. 5:21. This is a sobering thought to the most ardent proponents of lingering hell-fire. If the gospel is what it is, we can place no value upon it unless we are reconciled to God by the death of His Son. To say that death is not the penalty for our sins is to deny the gospel and to make the vicarious atonement of Christ on Calvary an insufficient and futile sacrifice.

This subject is also related to the very na­ture and purpose of God. True justice requires that the punishment be in direct proportion to the guilt. Whatever is more than this is cruelty. It is injustice. So, to describe God as one whose cruelty knows no bounds is to invest Him with a character that is depraved and vicious. What Christian would want to be guilty of that? 

Finally, how does this doctrine harmonize with the eternal and unchanging purpose of God? Sin and suffering are not and never were a part of His plan for mankind. They are of the devil, and the Lord has no intention of perpetuating these evils. Instead of unending pain and sorrow and perpetual sin, "there shall be no more curse." Rev. 22:3. The justice of God does not frustrate His mercy. Rather, it opens the way for His mercy to be realized. It ensures the eradication of evil for all eternity and makes possible the complete restoration of all things in harmony with the original pur­pose of an all-wise Creator. The whole creation of God, throughout the boundless realms of His universe, is thus seen to rejoice in the magnitude of His victory over sin.

Surely such fundamental principles as the gospel of our Lord Jesus, the character of God, and His unchangeable purpose toward us offer as solid a foundation as can be had for the teaching of this important subject, "The Penalty for Sin." Let us build on these strong and widely accepted principles in presenting the highly controverted points of our doctrine, that the way might be well prepared for their ac­ceptance.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

Bv Louis F. CUNNINGHAM, Licensed Minister, Chesapeake Conference

September 1949

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

A Study in Leadership

The book of Esther is the story of an acute crisis in the experience of God's people. It reveals, as do many other stories of the Bible, that God is with His people under all conditions. When a great leader for Israel was required the Lord provided one, usually from some obscure source.

The Spirit of Prophecy Apocrypha

There is always something very intriguing about a hearsay report. It gives one a feeling of importance to relate something that not everyone has access to or knows about, espe­cially some statement attributed to Mrs. White, which "for some reason" did not get into her books.

Evangelism in Present-Day Germany

The years 1946-1947 were in the truest sense of the word years of reconstruction. Our ministers served the various congregations which had been quickly gathered together again, and searched for interested souls. We now have fifteen new and reconstructed chap­els.

Village Evangelism in Basutoland

In planning an evangelistic program for these villages, it is wise to go straight to the chief.

Evangelism in the Gold Coast

As in most mission fields, the staff of the Gold Coast Mission is made up of full-time evangelists and teacher-evangelists. The teacher evangelists teach school during the week and engage in the church worship period and other soul-winning services during the week end.

"Wings for the Message"

The prayer of a mother in Birmingham, England, whose son was being ordained to the ministry, This was read after the ordination charge.

Bible Reading Texts

How many texts should be used in a Bible reading?

Devices for Illustrating Truth

The need for visual aids in evangelism is becoming more apparent.

Is There a Second Chance?

How comforting it would be to think there would be a second chance for the sinner, because there are so many things in this life that attract him.

Pyramids, Israel, and Sojourn

Did the Israelites help build the pyramids of Egypt, as the British-Israel advocates claim?

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - SermonView - Medium Rect (300x250)

Recent issues

See All