Religious Groups in Our Evangelism

Religious Groups in Our Evangelism (Part III)

We here continue the discussion begun in the preceding number of THE MINISTRY on our approaches to other Protestant groups.

L.C.K. is an associate editor of the Ministry. 

We here continue the discussion begun in the preceding number of THE MINISTRY on our approaches to other Protestant groups. This brief series ties in with a 1956 Book Club suggestion, A Guide to the Religions of America. In this interesting book by Leo Rosten, edited from the recent Look magazine series, we are informed on the main present-day beliefs and practices of these various Christian groups. The purpose of these reviews in our journal is to present a few points that may help the gospel worker to be tactful and helpful in his approaches to these groups.

The Episcopalians

The Episcopal Church has a large member­ship throughout the world. It is patterned after its Anglican mother overseas. We learn from W. Norman Pittenger, the Look historian for his denomination, that the group recognizes a "high," a "low," and a "broad" church, and also a variety of liberalism. "Episcopalians appeal to Scriptures, tradition, and personal experience, as well as reason, for vindication of the truth of the Christian faith. Differences of emphasis are welcomed in the Episcopal Church, as long as the central affirmations are maintained."—A Guide to the Religions of America, p. 54.

Although the Scriptures are a great testing ground of doctrine, the Episcopal Church does not hold to the inerrancy of Scripture. Its priest­hood and its polity generally are Catholic. There is a common loyalty with the see of Canterbury. However, it defines itself as being both Catholic and Protestant.

It is of interest to Adventists that the Episco­pal stand on drinking and gambling is "non-puritanical." The Episcopal Church believes that God intends that men enjoy life. On this, as well as card playing and dancing, the church has been liberal in attitude.

Although some Episcopalians stress the second advent of Christ, their interpretation is hardly a message according to Adventist understanding.

Creedal in nature more than Bible centered, the church clings to orthodoxy on the Trinity and such doctrines as the virgin birth. Again, it neither stresses nor condemns auricular con­fession. To us this would suggest compromise. But there are also stronger elements in this denomination that we should recognize as we make contacts with its members. Such doctrines as the Trinity, the atonement, and the death and resurrection of Christ are points held in com­mon, and suggest where the gospel worker may begin discussing the Bible. Instruction on baptism and the Lord's Supper requires re­straint when teaching Episcopalians. In this case it helps to be informed on the historical and doctrinal background of the group.

The Episcopal Church is missionary-minded. It carried a prominent part in the early history of America. It has some just pride in its national traditions. Here we may find other points of contact.

The Methodists

Next we will consider the Methodist Church. Dr. Ralph W. Sockman was selected to discuss his group in Look magazine. As a recognized ministerial authority, with fame on the National Radio Pulpit for more than twenty-six years, he defines a Methodist as "a unique blend of New Testament Christianity, the Protestant Reforma­tion, and the influence of John Wesley." Methodism's roots were in Anglicanism. The denomination is not as traditional as individu­alistic, which fact accounts for its founder, John Wesley. The movement began in the spirit of prayer and with an interest in the more neg­lected. This group, Oxford's Holy Club, stressed rules of conduct and religious observance. Its sincerity and zeal soon provided another reli­gious body, which in America grew into a "Methodist Church" the name derived from its methodical precepts and habits of devotion.

Methodism introduced some changes and modifications of Anglicanism. Its emphasis on grace and holiness, its less ritualistic creedal ways, its lively interest in temperance and re­form, in the New World developed various shadings of Methodism. Here was excellent soil where the rights and needs of the individual could find expansion. The 9,000,000 Methodists in the United States form a part of the 14,500,­000 throughout the world. The group has con­tributed much to civilization. Here we might add that the Salvation Army was influenced by, and is a contemporary of, Methodism. As far as polity, Adventism absorbed much of Meth­odism. Also Methodism greatly encouraged us in our earlier reformatory interests.

We are likely to discover that our good friends the Methodists are in danger of losing their earlier zeal for important reforms, such as those to correct the liquor and tobacco habits. In the field of doctrine we recognize an overemphasis on grace as related to the law of God. It is here that we should seek to arrive at a better under­standing with Methodists. They will claim that Adventism has "another gospel"—salvation by the keeping of the law. Our emphasis on obedience to all God's commandments must not eclipse the truth that man is saved by the aton­ing blood of Christ, not by the law. We believe with the Methodists that obedience is merely the fruit of salvation, through the spilled blood on Calvary. Akin to this doctrine is that of grace and holiness. True holiness is progressive Christian living on every point of revealed light. Methodism has holiness confused with perfec­tionism of an instantaneous nature. In teaching our message it pays to be understanding and more kind than dogmatic. Many Seventh-day Adventists had their roots in Methodism.

Before we leave Methodism in our discussions we should mention its dispensational teachings. Methodism today is alerted on Bible prophecy, but has adopted the Catholic Futurist interpre­tation, thereby losing the strength of prophecy. Strangely, the many shadings of these Futurist interpretations are confusing and contradictory to the Bible student who is aware of the historicist interpretation as being the only sound system. Rapturists look for Christ's soon return, but have sadly overlooked a study of Advent prophecies in their proper context. Methodists are not alone in this respect. Other fundamentalist groups have followed Dr. C. I. Scofield of Bible renown, an interpreter of prophecy. He borrowed his system from the Plymouth Brethren, who revived the Futurist system of the Counter Reformation during the early decades of the nineteenth century. In it church history is arbitrarily divided into con­venient "dispensations." Chronology is definitely thrown out of alignment. Eschatological views center around the Antichrist of prophecy and the return of the Jews to their native Palestine. An elaborate rabbinism is to be reinstated after the "rapture," which will be seven )ears before the "revelation of Christ."

Most controversial is the antinomian teaching that the dispensation of law in the Old Testa­ment is followed by the dispensation of grace in the New. Grace is interpreted as freedom from obedience to the Ten Commandments, and more specifically from observing the true seventh-day Sabbath. Intending to be fundamen­tal, this system of interpretation courts modern­ism. We claim in all humility that Adventism has recognized the deceiving character of this confusion and has a strong prophetic message for the hour.

Holiness-Pentecostal Groups

Today there is a new emphasis on miracles and the charismatic and healing gifts. However, the gift of the Holy Spirit has been interpreted in the "tongues movement," with its question­able confusions and often undignified desecra­tions of the house of God. Extremes of these "excitements" are still recognized in our Ameri­can hinterland areas. "Independent" groups revel in their individualism and often disown their Methodist Christian ancestry. The gospel worker should never think of ridiculing such extremisms. Some sincere truth seekers may be readily led astray, but the Word of God still separates the chaff from the wheat. Adventism has some very sane, clear light on true holiness. We have a background of experience with specious types of holiness after the 1844 move­ment. Adventists stress that advancing in holiness also requires carefulness in diet, and that health­ful living is important in the process of sanctifi­cation. There is greater power in living health­fully than in the claims of modern "faith healers." But we need not disparage the true gift of healing in the church. Again, a sanctified people will keep a sanctified rest day. Our teachings on the Christian Sabbath may have a real appeal for holiness seekers.

The Quakers

It is here convenient to bring the Quakers into our discussion of religious bodies. Quaker­ism became a nickname for the followers of George Fox in England. It was during the turbulent seventeenth century, at the magis­trates' trial in Derby, that they "trembled at the Word of God." This quaint group has made its contributions to religion, especially in the New World. Quakers claim that they form a "third way," not being Protestant or Roman Catholic.

With Evangelicals and Adventists they strongly hold that God can be approached directly, with­out an intermediary priest or preacher.

Quakers hold that God is experienced through the "Inner Light." They were formerly called Children of the Light and Friends of the Truth because they keep an open mind to truth re­vealed, and yet to be revealed.

Simplicity in dress, piety in worship, and spiritual fellowship distinguish their faith. Their worthy reforms, their clean way of life, and their philanthropy suggest a common tie with Adventism. However, Quaker doctrines to us lack certainty. Quakerism needs a definite mes­sage of Christ's imminent return. Bible doctrines must be pointed out to the Quaker with new significance.

Again we note that "service," the Quaker term for missionary work, is a worthy endeavor for the church in these last days. It would seem to us that the hour will come when our friends the Quakers will respond to a message of the soon return of Christ in person. If the instructor is to share such a message with them they must see a quality of quiet sincerity in her.

L. C. K.

(Continued next month)


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

L.C.K. is an associate editor of the Ministry. 

June 1956

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Evangelism—A Principle, Not an Expedient

Evangelism is to the church what wings are to a bird! Clip the wings and the bird falters in its flight and finally ends up creeping! An odd position for a bird—creeping!

Our Daily Bread

The petition, "Give us this day our daily bread," is more than an illustration of the depth and breadth and height of the loving care of God.

How to Plan a Program for the Church Year

The important role of planning and preparation to preaching.

Intemperance—An Inveterate Evil

We may think of intemperance as the octopus of sin. It is an inveterate evil that can strike at the heart of even a preacher.

Are you an evangelist?

All who are authorized to preach are evangelists by act and not by method.

What Doest Thou Here?

One of the most thrillingly interesting and dramatic meetings it has ever been my pleasure to attend was a gathering of some four hundred Protestant missionaries in Central China.

The Distinctiveness in Adventist Preaching

A preacher can be the best Adventist in his church, and every minister should be, and yet not make his ministry and preaching dis­tinctively Adventist.

A Reasonable Worship

What did Paul mean by "reasonable service" in Romans 12?

What About Our Atomic Bomb Sermons?

How much the seeming imminence of war affect our discourse and sermons?

Lengthen and Strengthen

The Scriptural admonition to "lengthen thy cords, and strengthen thy stakes" is wise counsel for every branch of the Lord's work in these last days. Particularly fitting is this for our Theological Seminary, the capstone of our denomination's educational structure.

Eschatology and Time

What is the concept of time in the Old and New Testament?

How Often Should the Lord's Supper Be Celebrated?

There is certainly no uniformity in this matter among Christian bodies generally. So what do the Scriptures say?

Mothering the Multitudes (Part III)

The Role of the Minister's Wife in Safeguarding the Mental Health of the Church

A Medical Evangelism Experiment

A report from our Conference in Central California.

The Minister's Spiritual Life

I believe the minister's spiritual life is of importance in view of the fact that we can spend days and weeks of time with plans and methods, yet if our own personal relation to God should not be right, it profiteth nothing.

Conserving New Converts

Eight steps to retain church members.

Pointer's to Progress

Monthly pulpit pointer's by the Ministry staff.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)