A Non-Adventist Leader Examines Our Beliefs

Book reviews on Questions on Doctrine continue to come to our desk.

R.A.A. is editor of the Ministry.

BOOK reviews on Questions on Doctrine con­tinue to come to our desk. Aside from one or two prejudiced reviewers, all have been favorable, some outstandingly so. But it is espe­cially gratifying when one comes from a recog­nized authority such as Dr. Frank S. Mead. He is an incisive and stimulating commentator on the contemporary church scene, and for years has served as consulting editor to a number of large religious publishing houses and institu­tions. A Methodist by church affiliation, he is the author of a number of books, the latest being Handbook of Denominations in the United States. He has also been editor of such journals as Christian Herald and The Homiletic Review. Few men in the United States exert a wider influence in the field of religious reading. His evaluation should therefore prove an en­couragement and inspiration.

In his review in Religion in Life, winter quarter, 1958-1959, he says:

Aside from being something of a publishing mira­cle (720 pages for $1.50!) this is an elaborate work of doctrinal clarification, written by a group of Sev­enth-day Adventist writers, counselors and editors. Lacking the imprimatur of their General Confer­ence, it is not "official," but an explanation and ex­pansion of their Fundamental Beliefs (pp. 11-18). There is nothing new about it, nor was there in­tended to be; it may win no converts, but it should correct many an error and unenlightened criticism on the part of those who have never quite under­stood what it is all about. For these it was written.

These Adventists, we gather, have more in com­mon with conservative Christianity than most con­servative Christians seem willing to admit; many of their items of faith have close parallels in orthodox Protestantism. But they take "one of two or more alternate views" on "certain controverted doctrines" (on salvation, immortality, baptism, hell and pun­ishment, etc.), while on others they are still pecul­iarly Seventh-day (on the heavenly sanctuary, the investigative judgment, the interpretation of Rev­elation, and the unique position and contribution of Ellen G. White). The attempt to explain Mrs. White (she was neither prophet nor prophetess but a "messenger" with the gift of the Spirit of proph­ecy) will leave some still in confusion if not in doubt; but on the whole the book is refreshing in its clarity and candor. They know Whom they have believed, and what, and why. They show a freedom of interpretation and expression which will surprise many beyond the pale, commanding respect if not agreement. It is one of the ablest and most compre­hensive books available in the field of denomina­tional doctrine and, thank heaven and the editors, it is actually readable. Even the layman can enjoy it!

While Doctor Mead has reservations regard­ing some areas of our theology, yet his frank statement that Adventists have "more in com­mon with conservative Christianity" than many have hitherto believed is important. We are sure our readers will appreciate this forthright appraisal, and the reviewer's recognition that this book in no way compromises our faith.

R. A. A.

Advertisement - Ministry in Motion 300x250

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

R.A.A. is editor of the Ministry.

May 1959

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

"Adorn the Doctrine"

There is no element in the preacher's life that is of more importance than his example.

Convincing Evidences

Just now, forty years and more after Ellen White laid down her pen, new items of clear, confirming evidence of her gift of inspiration are being discovered and presented to the public in an unprecedented manner Newspapers, magazines, and books all around us pile up evidence regarding her veracity.

The Gift That Builds

To read all of Mrs. White's writings will indeed be a major task, but a spiritually profitable one.

Our Minister

Our preacher knew just what to say to soothe the hurt in our hearts and to encourage us to faithfulness in the face of taunts and sneers on the part of our non-Adventist classmates.


Essential Steps to Success in the Ministry-2

What Kind of "Voice" Are You?

There is no doubt that John the Baptist was one of the most successful preachers the world has ever known

To "Every Nation . . ." The Divine Command to a Universal Church

A world-embracing task confronts God's people today.

The Middle East--Cradle of Strife!

Ever since Noah's ark docked somewhere in the vicinity of Mount Ararat, the leading na­tions of the world have managed to focus their sights on that ge­ographical area that is today commonly referred to as the Middle East.

The Evangelical World Prospect: An Interview with Billy Graham

Reprinted by permission, Christianity Today, Oct. 13, 1958

Evangelistic Techniques in Britain

The writer has recently had the privilege of conducting city-wide campaigns in two of Britain's largest cities, Bir­mingham and Manchester.

Planning an Evangelistic Campaign Part II

Revivalism and evangelism should not be confused. Both are indispensable, but they ought to be distinct in method of approach, in purpose, and in the type of sermons presented.

Ideals for Mothers

The monthly shepherdess column.

Socials for the Entire Church

Successful church entertainments can help us reach our goals. A presentation to the Texas Conference Shepherdess Group.

Basic Training for Personal Evangelism

The term "personal worker" requires a new emphasis in an hour when there is true need for this type of worker.

Are You a Breakfast Skipper?

"Eat a Good Breakfast—Start a Good Day."

The Highest Career

Does the spirit of ambition threaten to de­prive some of our workers of the joy that re­sults from humble and faithful work in God's cause?

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - Healthy and Happy Family - Skyscraper 160x600