An Indispensable Element in Worship

Music has proved to be an indispensable element in religious services, as an adjunct to worship as well as evangelism. It has proved to be a great source of contro­versy, probably because it is a property that belongs to everyone, not just a few. Music has been called the "handmaiden of religion," and is used as a vehicle for the expression of man's religious spirit.

Organist, Claremont, California, Church

MUSIC has proved to be an indispensable element in religious services, as an ad­junct to worship as well as evangelism. It has proved to be a great source of contro­versy, probably because it is a property that belongs to everyone, not just a few. Music has been called the "handmaiden of religion," and is used as a vehicle for the expression of man's religious spirit.

The noted churchman, Luther D. Reed, has said—

Religion is the deepest concern of the human spirit. Music is the most powerful exponent of hu­man emotion. It is natural, therefore, that music should reach its greatest heights—attain to its pur­est expressions—in the service of religion. 1

Music in our churches has become con­troversial because what is worship for one person may be merely noise for another. Worship is a very personal experience. However, in the church service, in addi­tion to being a personal experience it must also serve a group. Music for worship, ei­ther corporate or individual, must serve to invoke meditation, quietude, reverence, praise, or a combination of these.

Sometimes people think of their favorite religious music as that which was familiar to our Lord when He was ministering on earth. However, in reality, the music Christ knew would sound quite foreign and dis­sonant to Western ears. The plain song at­tributed to the time of Pope Gregory I, who died in the year a.d. 604, comes as close to the music of the time of Christ as any gen­erally known. It is the earliest known Chris­tian music.

In considering music it is well to con-sider the motives of the composer. It was Johann Sebastian Bach, considered the fa­ther of modern church music, who said, "All music should be composed for the glory of God and the permissible delecta­tion of the mind; otherwise it is nothing but a devilish hubbub." A composer could not have a more noble or honorable ob­jective for his work. But here we see that mere motivation may not have much con­sequence, for many sincere people are un­able to derive satisfaction of any nature from hearing the music of Bach. However, apparently Bach succeeded in his work, for his music is used today in the worship of God more than it has ever been used before.

A prominent church musician, Carl Hal­ter, has stated:

The chief, and perhaps only, difference between the music of the Church and secular music is a dif­ference in function. Where secular music is free to address itself to any of man's emotions, the music of the Church is restricted to serving the Word of God, its presentation to man, and man's response to the Word. Church music is never an end in itself, nor is its function to entertain. 2

Ellen Gould White states:

Music was made to serve a holy purpose, to lift the thoughts to that which is pure, noble, and ele­vating, and to awaken in the soul devotion and gratitude to God. . . .

Music forms a part of God's worship in the courts above, and we should endeavor, in our songs of praise, to approach as nearly as possible to the harmony of the heavenly choirs. 3

The servant of the Lord has put before us a high challenge: to approach the har­mony of the heavenly choirs. In actuality, this is a dilemma. To some the harmony of the heavenly choir would be the singing of the frenzied "holy rollers," to others it would be the other extreme. There are few absolutes that fit all situations in music. If one is to accept the beliefs of author­ities in church music, a little study reveals that historians are generally agreed that the high point of church music was reached during the time of Palestrina, who lived during the Golden Age, or the Renaissance. That music is still with us, and scholars are agreed that it remains unequaled in the realm of religious music. Thus it would fol­low that the polyphonic music of the age of Palestrina, representing man's great achievement in the realm of church music, would come as close to the sound of the heavenly choirs as any man-made music. The late Joseph W. Clokey stated that— The purpose of worship is to elevate, not to de­grade. The quality of the music used should be above rather than below the cultural level of the congregation. If the music seems to be "over your head" the best plan is to raise your head. 4

We have seen some very exalted ideals for music proposed by Ellen G. White. She says: "Singing, as a part of religious service, is as much an act of worship as is prayer." 5

She also says— Music has occupied the hours which should have been devoted to prayer. 6

Again quoting Joseph Clokey: From the first the Church has taught that the fin­est of human expression should be dedicated to the glory of God. Less than the best is sacrilege. There­fore great cathedrals have been built. They are filled with treasures of stained glass, sculpture, and painting. Great musicians have devoted their crea­tive genius to the music of the Church. The grand total of sacred art is overwhelming in its magnifi­cence.

But this very magnificence is at once a danger. When religion relies too much on professionalism it defeats itself. Worship becomes a mere esthetic ex­perience. Cathedrals become museums, the Liturgy becomes a show. 7

Luther Reed says:

Music that is not good service music is an in­truder in public worship, no matter how beautiful it may be in itself. . . . Concertistic character it must not have. . . . Organ transcriptions which bring the literature of the orchestra into the sanctuary, florid musical masses composed in operatic style and sung dramatically, quartet choirs with ostentatious dis­play of individual vocal powers and excessive solo performances of whatever character—all are out of order in the church. 8

The layman often says, "I know nothing about music, but I know what I like." If you know nothing about music, then learn something. You will get more satisfaction out of what you like if you know something about it.

The man in the pews has a perfect right to have his likes and dislikes, but they should be based on something more substantial than mere caprice. Re­ligion is no mere caprice. The Church is no mere caprice. And the music of the Church should not be determined by anyone's whim, be he layman, minister, or musician. 9

Worship has two directions, from man to God and from God to man. A hymn of praise, a prayer, . . . these are man-to-God. The reading of the Holy Scriptures, the benediction, these are God-to-man.

Whenever the direction is man-to-man, that is not worship. If much man-to-man direction creeps into a religious service, worship will be crowded out. The direction of secular music is man-to­man. 10

Bearing these factors in mind, an analy­sis of the music which is to be used in a re­ligious service becomes an easier matter. Music should be selected to fit each specific occasion. Music in a religious service should be functional, and should be se­lected very carefully, in consideration of its intended function.

While music does belong to everyone and is the common property of the people, its use in religious services should not lower it to the least common denominator. It should serve to elevate its auditors and per­formers. Because of the emotional appeal of music, it must be used with discretion, and should not be used to compensate for the shortcomings of the spoken word.

While music and worship are both verv personal things, the corporate aspects of religious services should also be considered, and the music should be used to serve the functions of corporate worship.

Where worship is man to God and God to man, a hymn can best serve the purpose. Where the service indicates the music should be of a testimonial, or man-to-man nature, a gospel song would be appropri­ate. These two occasions and functions should not be confused.

Ibid Instead of limiting the concept of the heavenly choirs by our own experience and ideas, let us elevate our own concepts to serve the Lord with the finest that we are able to offer.

 1 Luther D. Reed, Worship (Muhlenberg Press, Phil­adelphia), p. 158.

2 Carl Halter, The Practice of Sacred Music (Con­cordia Publishing House, St. Louis), p. 8.

3 Ellen G. White, Patriarchs and Prophets (Pacific Press, Mountain View), p. 594.

4 Joseph W. Clokey, In Every Corner Sing (Morehouse-Barlow Co., New York), pp. 20. 21.

5 Ellen G. White, Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 594.

6---------, Testimonies to the Church, vol. 1, p. 506.

7 Clokey, op. cit., p. 10.

8 Reed, op. cit., p. 18.

9 Clokey, op. cit., p. 1.

10 Ibid., p. 5.

Advertisement - Digital Discipleship (300x250)

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

Organist, Claremont, California, Church

April 1962

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Pointers for Preachers

Machinery or Mission, Shepherding the Flock, "The Old Ring"

Candles in the Night -- No. 6

God has always reserved for Himself men and women who would minister to every need of His children. The history of the Christian church abounds in lov­ing humanitarian service. No need has been overlooked and no area excluded. This was true when Elizabeth Fry (1780-1845), a Quaker minister, became burdened for the inmates of Newgate Prison in London.

Freedom from Fear

A Bible study.

How to Work for Jehovah's Witnesses

It is just six years since I had the joy of seeing my first Jehovah's Witnesses family step out and accept the Advent mes­sage. Although this family had been connected to the Witnesses for more than eighteen years, and have relatives still in that organization, they are loyal Seventh-day Adventists today, actively working to spread the message for these days.

Ten Times to Call the Minister or an Elder

At our recent elders' coun­cil, we spent much time discussing ways in which we as ministers and local elders can be of greater help to our people.

Evangelism, 1962!

A new day is dawning for public evangelism! The idea that the day of the public meeting is past is being for­gotten and the vision of true evangelism is dawning again. Thank God for it!

The Message of the Empty Tomb

Christianity is founded upon an empty tomb." So said Thomas Payne in derision. But that scornful remark is a tremendous truth. Were there no empty tomb there would be no Christian church.

The Breaking of Bread in Acts 20:7-11

In meeting the argument that Acts 20:7-11 proves that Christians observed Sunday as a sacred day in apostolic times, a few of our ministers have denied, sometimes even in print, that Paul and the believers at Troas partook of the Communion, or Lord's Supper, on that occasion. However sincere they may have been in using this counter argument, it is a mistaken one in so far as Seventh-day Adventist teaching is concerned. Hence we deem it fitting to caution our workers that such a position is not only untenable, but it may also result in embarrassment both to him who uses it and to the cause that he represents.

"Unto the High Place"

What are the conditions in our day that will cause our wayward and confused young people to come to us for help? There must be a way to span the barrier that too often exists between the pastor and the youthful members of his flock.

Some Books I Can Recommend

Book recommendations from Lyndon K. McDowell.

Great Words of the Bible—No. 9: Atonement (c)-"Kopher" and "Lutron"

The thought of covering, which the previous article showed to be a valid meaning of the word so often translated "to make an atonement," is continued in the words related to kaphar.

We Don't Make the Rules

The modern disposition to soften the judgments of God by trying to change the rules may prove to be an extremely costly experiment in morals. And in view of the desperate struggle in which we are en­gaged, it ill behooves us to make mistakes.

Conservative or Contemporary Church Style?

There are various views on church architecture. Some­times we present viewpoints that are regarded as modern­istic, sometimes the conservative angle is presented. The author of this article gives his views as a contribution to the important subject of church architecture, so vital to many of our readers.

Are You Satisfied With Your Life?

A sermon given in the Temple City church, Glendale, California.

Righteousness by Faith: Concluded

The Master's pronouncements are all master statements, infinitely profound, yet marvelously simple. His meaning is clear: I am your spiritual life. Attached to Me, your life is clean and your witness faithful. Apart from Me, you can do nothing.

The New Being

To have a complete idea of Pauline doc­trine, the new creation and its implications must be understood.

The Man Who Lived Again

The resurrection, mentioned 104 times in the New Testament, became the central doctrine of the early church—a cornerstone of Christianity. May the same great power be upon Christ's ministers today as they bear wit­ness of the resurrection.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated


Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)