For an Effective Ministry

WHAT priorities do seminaries maintain in training ministers? Do scholarly concerns eclipse spiritual values and curtail evangelism?

-retired attorney

WHAT priorities do seminaries maintain in training ministers? Do scholarly concerns eclipse spiritual values and curtail evangelism?

While dining at a religious conference one day, I was startled by what I saw on a place mat. It was an advertisement for a prominent Protestant seminary, and in big print it said, "For a Learned Ministry." As I read further I found out that this seminary was preparing men and women for a vocation that is "scholarly and effective." The advertisement pointed out the academic qualifications of faculty members, boasting that they had "written fifty-eight books and numerous scholarly articles" and that they "lecture frequently at conferences." Then came the climactic tribute, apparently intended to be overwhelming: "Their creativity has already made a significant impact on the theological thinking of this age."

Now I am certainly not opposed to scholarship in the seminaries. There have been great scholars in the Church—Augustine, Luther, Calvin, Hodge, and many more—and the product of their minds blessed by the Holy Spirit has been in valuable in the proclamation of the Gospel and in the progress of Christianity. What disturbed me about this advertisement was that there was no reference to spiritual values, to the faith and dedication of students and faculty, nor was there any suggestion that these things are important. There was no hint that this seminary tries to prepare students to witness for Christ or to preach the Gospel. One must conclude that its objective is to turn out learned graduates well trained by teachers who write scholarly books and lecture frequently.

As I reread the place mat, I remembered a letter I had recently received from another seminary; it stated that the seminary had no creed, and the accompanying brochure said, "It is time to reaffirm that the very core of the seminary is its concern for the scholarly pastor. . . ."

All this brought a barrage of questions to my mind. What do they mean by a "learned" ministry? By an "effective" ministry? What does a trophy case filled with fifty-eight books and numerous scholarly articles prove about a faculty's fitness for preparing students to proclaim Christ's message of salvation? And what kind of books and articles were these? Did they have spiritual as well as scholarly value? Do "published" teachers rate higher in this seminary than those who might witness for Christ in less erudite ways?

What does "creative activity" include? What kind of "significant impact" has it made on theological thinking? Has it been good or bad? Have the faculty members of this seminary, directly or indirectly, led fifty-eight people to Christ? Have they led one? Have they tried to? Do they believe in apostolic evangelism and preaching the Gospel? Or are they trying to substitute scholarship for the gospel message pro claimed in the power and the presence of the Holy Spirit? Do they use their learning for the honor of Christ and the extension of his kingdom?

While pondering these questions, I remembered that the greatest teacher of all time never went to college, never wrote a book or an article, never delivered a formal lecture. When he talked about God to a little child or to a politician, he didn't use five-syllable words and hundred-word sentences. Most of the apostles he chose were amazingly successful evangelists who went everywhere preaching the Gospel courageously and wisely. None of the twelve would be considered "learned" or "scholarly"—yet they certainly were "effective." What was their primary qualification? It was this: They knew what they proclaimed, and they proclaimed it in the power of the Holy Spirit. The rulers and elders at Jerusalem, "when they saw the boldness of Peter and John, and perceived that they were unlearned and ignorant men, . . . marvelled; and they took knowledge of them that they had been with Jesus" (Acts 4:13).

A minister's scholarly attainment is of great value when used for the glory of God and for the forthright proclamation of the Gospel. Many great preachers were scholars. And many scholars witness very effectively for the faith they hold. But scholarship must never be considered the most important qualification for the ministry, or the primary goal of the seminaries.

What a wave of evangelism would cleanse this country if every Protestant seminary gave top priority to turning out those who clearly "had been with Jesus."


Copyright 1968 by Christianity Today; reprinted by permission.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-retired attorney

November 1969

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Barnabas--Ministerial Recruiter

BARNABAS is one of the lesser known of the apostolic missionaries who was scattered abroad from Jerusalem when persecution was begun against the infant Christian church, but judging from the few scriptural passages making reference to him, he must have been a successful trainer of ministers—young ministers. . .

Wither Too or Whither To? No. 2

LEIGHTON FORD'S opening remarks at the recent U.S. Congress on Evangelism have particular bearing on the Advent Movement. Fie tells of the inscription found on a huge granite pillar erected over the grave of Karl Marx, the father of Communism. It declares, "The philosophers have interpreted the world. The point is to change it.". . .

Easier Board Meetings?

AFTER pastoring a certain church nearly three years, it was evident that many of the urgently needed building repairs were not being done. This, along with disagreement as to just what projects should be done and how, shoddy workmanship on some past projects, lack of proper supervision, and other related problems, gave rise to a bold new idea—new at least to us. . .

Positive Evidence for Sabbath Observance in the New Testament (Part 1)

BIBLICAL theology and anthropology envision God as Creator and man as creature, and the supreme goal of man's existence to be to apprehend God, to enter into a vital relationship with Him, and voluntarily to fulfill the Creator's purpose for him. To this end God ordained a special revelation of Himself, a special place where man might commune with Him, and a special time for such communion—the Scripture, the temple, and the Sabbath. In this study we are concerned with the attitude and practice of Christ and His followers with respect to Sabbath observance in New Testament times. . .

A Plea for More Awkwardness

WE HEAR innumerable pleas for balance and symmetry. But like most other theories symmetry does not always perform all the wonders we expect, simply because we do not realize the rather unsymmetrical process by which symmetry comes to be. For life gets on by jerks and bounces quite as much as it does by the gliding process. . .

"As Thy Days. . ."

HENRY VAN DYKE, one time professor of English in Princeton University, and moderator of the Presbyterian Church in the United States, gave to the world a clear formula for successful living. . .

Don't Do It All

SOME ministers try to perform all the duties of the church by themselves. They spend long hours preparing their Sabbath sermon and half as many more for the midweek prayer service. Beyond this, fundraising campaigns, board and committee meetings, members' personal problems, visits to the sick, funerals and weddings, et cetera, occupy so much time that the pastor has little time or zest for his real job, which is fulfilling the gospel commission (Matt. 28:19). . .

Can You Wear the Mantle of Revival Leadership?

WE ARE talking about something we really know and we are witnessing to something we have actually observed." These words of Jesus as recorded in the Gospel of John, chapter 3, verse 11, Phillips,* should be the testimony of every Seventh-day Adventist worker serving in the most challenging hour of this world's history. . .

The Remnant Sinless— When? How?

WHAT is involved in the blotting out of the overcomer's sins in the judgment now in session? Does it include, as some claim, the erasing of inborn sin and the scars of sin from his nature when he is sealed?

The Spectacular

IF AN unconverted circus manager ever sot to heaven, can you imagine what o J O would occupy his time? He probably would try to talk Daniel into challenging the lions again. Lazarus would get top billing as a man who died and was resurrected twice. Enoch, the first earthly space traveler on record, would be immediately contacted with a contract for public appearances. Joshua's act of stopping the sun, if repeated, would guarantee a large attendance. Heading the list would be the Master Himself. . .

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - RevivalandReformation 300x250

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)