Abortion?

As could and should be expected, public opinion is irreconcilably divided. The division is not along the lines of Christian and non-Christian belief. Even in the Christian church camp different values are assessed separately and the differences do not always fall along denominational lines. . .

IN MANY areas of the world today considerable interest has been generated in the reform of abortion laws to cover more contingencies. This interest has reached a loud clamor in some circles. Liberation activists find in this uproar the elements of a new humanitarian cause. In fact, the result has been the enactment of more liberal abortion laws, such as those adopted in New York State in April, 1970.

Immediately, well-meaning people have rushed to establish abortion counseling, in formation, and referral services to offer aid to women who might be seeking safe, legal, hospital and hospital-affiliated clinic abortions at reasonable cost. Some of these agencies also offer practical alternatives to abortion and refer women to prenatal clinics, homes for unwed mothers, adoption services, psychiatric and/or religious counseling services, et cetera.

The telephone switchboard of one of these agencies was completely inadequate. It was reported that hundreds of callers constantly received the busy signal. From the start it looked as though abortions might become big business.

As could and should be expected, public opinion is irreconcilably divided. The division is not along the lines of Christian and non-Christian belief. Even in the Christian church camp different values are assessed separately and the differences do not always fall along denominational lines.

The Need for Careful Thought

Certainly Seventh-day Adventist physicians and ministers will need to think clearly on the matter of standards and guidelines. Both represent the spiritual and ethical outreach of the church, and the fact that they are asking for a serious discussion of the factors involved is a heartening indication. We are aware, however, that discussion will reveal considerable diversity of viewpoint.

One physician states the case bluntly as follows: "It will be tragic indeed if our church should support the free and willful destruction of human life [abortion for convenience], while urging those who are of military age not to bear arms in order to refrain from taking life—even that of the enemy."

Responsible leaders of the church and physicians have adopted suggestive guide lines for therapeutic abortions that might need to be performed in denominational hospitals in the United States. We think it would be well at the present stage to publish these guidelines. At the same time a more exhaustive study of the matter has been initiated. A large committee of church leaders, denominational theologians, and medical professionals are spending and will continue to spend considerable time in research and dialog in an effort to assure that the cause of truth and humanity are recognized theologically and medically in this big area of concern today.

Why Abortions?

Perhaps a tentative review of present-day thinking and the motivations behind it could be helpful at this stage. First, why are abortions sought and under what conditions? A survey of the findings of obstetricians in the United States of America listed five points:

1. The prospective mother may be unwed with no definite prospects of marriage.

2. She may have been the victim of rape or incest.

3. She may have contracted German measles or taken thalidomide and fears that her child will be horribly deformed.

4. She may have some physical condition that pregnancy could aggravate to the point of endangering her life.

5. She may be an unwed child under fifteen years of age.

On the surface, an extension of legal abortion into the above areas would seem humane and practical. It must be pointed out, however, that less than one fifth of the estimated one million women who obtain illegal abortions in a year do so under these circumstances. Four fifths of the abortions fit the following description given by a director of obstetrics and gynecology at a large New York hospital: "A married woman with two or three children, at the height of child-bearing, between 28 and 40." To be sure, this fact greatly narrows the scope of the humanitarian problem.

Basic Issues

Now let us consider some of the basic issues that must be faced in determining a Christian attitude.

1. It must be recognized to start with that the right to life is not an unconditioned right. This is true even in the eyes of the most conservative moralists since they accept capital punishment, killing in self-defense, the assassination of tyrants, and generally abortion when the physical life of the mother is involved. The fact that the right to life is not an unconditioned right makes it impossible to find an absolute that would forbid the taking of human life in all circumstances.

2. This is an age of much dehumanization and little of what Albert Schweitzer called the "reverence for life." It certainly behooves Christians today, therefore, to speak out on behalf of life, especially of defenseless life. Current lack of "reverence for life" is possibly the most frightening aspect of our secularized world.

3. Closely related to the problem of "reverence for life" is the penalty sensitive mothers sometimes pay for many decades as a result of their "abortion for convenience." For many women this experience has shattered their psychological well-being. In such cases a feeling of guilt is harbored that is heightened by the constant sight of happy, growing children. One young mother (now not so young) revealed in a conversation how each time she met a child (and now a young lady or a young man), she was and is unable to thrust from her the question, "Would my child now be like that? Possibly I could be planning for a daughter's wedding." Such guilt complexes sometimes become a threat not only to mental but to physical health. In other words, a mother's psychological problems must have thought when the spectrum of abortion is under consideration.

4. For many the crux of the abortion problem really is whether or not the fetus is already a human life. When does the child become a "living being"? Is it such when it lives dependently in its mother's womb or only when later it lives independently outside it?

This problem can be considered from a medical and Biblical point of view. Medically, Dr. Andre E. Hellegers (Johns Hopkins University) lays stress on the stage of implantation five days after conception. There is presently no medical consensus on the timing of the identification of the human being. A considered judgment in this area by medical science would be helpful and interesting, be the time five days, three months, or eight months. However, for the moment there is here a gray area of apparent ignorance or unwillingness to take a stand.

The Biblical Approach

Biblically, scholars again are divided. Some consider the Bible teaches that the fetus becomes fully human at birth when it draws its first breath. Such cite passages like Genesis 2:7: "Then the Lord God formed man of dust from the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being" (R.S.V.). Special emphasis is given to the "breath" of life. The same word is found in the story of Elijah's healing the widow's son (1 Kings 17:17). Again, in the prophet Ezekiel's book, God said to the dry bones, "Behold, I will cause breath to enter into you, and we shall live" (Eze. 37:5). Actually, the Hebrew word is ruach and is translated as "soul," "life," or "breath," indicating etymologically that the Hebrews somehow connected breath, life, and being. Thus the entrance of "breath" at birth would start the "living being." Until that point the fetus simply would be a part of the mother's body.

On the other hand, the ecclesiast believed that "the spirit comes to the bones in the womb of a woman with child" (Eccl. 11:5, R.S.V.), although he gave no reason why he believed this or what the actual implication was. And when Elisabeth (the mother of John the Baptist) heard Mary's greeting, the baby within her leaped for joy (Luke 1:44). Would this indicate that it recognized the mother and participated in her life?

5. To be sure, in the Christian's scale of values (considering particularly number 1 above) the life of the fetus is not the only primary value to consider, though that life is weighted so heavily that only the most extreme circumstances could possibly be allowed to take precedence over it. For instance, though every year thousands of upper- and middle-class women have abortions, many more thousands, perhaps millions, also have abortions under unspeakable conditions. The suggestion is that perhaps just as some societies legalize gambling or prostitution, abortion should be legalized under precise circumstances as a lesser evil. Possibly laws should be reviewed and updated to fit better the actual situation. If abortions are to remain a fact, the evil is compounded by endangering the lives of the mothers and the reputation of physicians.

Possible Alternatives

6. When one considers the immense power of both technology and government, and the demoralizing invasion of secularism generally, considerate care should be the order of the day. All aspects of the problem should be in mind, including possible alternative suggestions to a liberalization of abortion laws beyond the area of therapeutic abortions. Perhaps society would find a better morality and more safety in promoting legislation to facilitate the care of unwanted babies under normal conditions amid signs of esteem and with expert medical care in order to assure them a decent delivery. And when the babies are born, can we not do more to assure proper care for them? Certainly here is an area where tax money would be justified to help women keep their babies instead of aborting them.

Human lives are precious. A mother who, under whatever circumstances, gives one to society, should be the object of consideration. She may have handled God's powers of creation in a wrong way, but God can forgive her, and society must.

All of this seemingly arrives at the conclusion that except in the extreme circumstances listed under our guidelines on therapeutic abortion, it would be better to enhance our reverence for life and the Christian way that leads to it.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

March 1971

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Abortion Is Not The Answer

WHILE driving on the freeway between Los Angeles and the airport recently, I followed a station wagon that was packed full of children, ten by actual count. A large bumper sticker became more obvious in relation to the many passengers inside as it blurted out "Abortion is not the answer."

Abortion Guidelines

In response to the many requests for a position on the abortion issue as it relates to the Seventh-day Adventist Church and the health care institutions it operates, the General Conference officers in consultation with its Department of Health have developed the following guidelines. It is recognized that these guidelines are not the final answer but perhaps can serve a useful purpose at the present time. . .

Please, Preacher--Pause!

JUST what does it take to win a soul to Jesus Christ in the sophisticated seventies?

Spiritual Overtones in the Ellen G. White Science Counsels

It is always helpful for the Seventh-day Adventist professional man or woman to keep in mind the spiritual goals of the Spirit of Prophecy writings whenever the Ellen G. White science counsels are explored.

Up With Summer!

Has the "ho hum" spirit caused a summer slump in your church?

Telephone Evangelism

FOR the past eight years we have operated a service in this city known as Dial-a- Prayer. During these years 2,750,000 calls have been made. . .

How to Be the Boss

Don't be like the leader who said, "There go my people; I must follow them, for I am their leader."

In Life-- In Death-- In Christ

It took a long time for the virus to do its deadly work. Too long. The two years of medication, hospitalization, of pain and suffering known only to the sufferer, were described by this woman of faith as a nightmare, and made her long to fall asleep in Jesus. In the prime of life, before the brush of middle age had lined her face or streaked her hair, this minister's wife was called to her final rest. And the age-old question automatically forms itself on our lips—why?

My Personal Part in the Ministry

WHEN I was asked to share something of my personal part in my husband's ministry, I thought, What do I really do to help him that is worthy of mention? There are countless things that every minister's wife probably does that are hardly significant enough to recount, like being his secretary, housekeeper, cook, et cetera. Are any of these my greatest contribution to his ministry?

Is the Sanitarium Obsolete?

In the 1880's, when the new medical institution at Battle Creek, Michigan was about to open, John Harvey Kellogg sent out brochures describing its advantages. The changes proposed by John Harvey Kellogg actually added a new word to the English language. . .

The Single Adult (Concluded)

WHEN we look below the surface of the single adult's personality, we find an other characteristic even more basic than loneliness. Anxiety, found in varying degrees, is a very realistic force within the modern young person. . .

Seventh-day Adventism and Eschatology (Concluded)

The ancient Jews, like ourselves, think of God's judgement in terms of an earthly court of justice. The difference is that the Christian pictures the case to be tried as a criminal case with himself in the dock; the Jew pictures it as a civil case with himself as the plaintiff. The one hopes for acquittal, or rather for pardon; the other hopes for a resounding triumph with heavy damages. . . .

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Trending

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - Healthy and Happy Family - Skyscraper 160x600