Thoughts on Colossians 2:14-17

THE objection is sometimes raised by those who do not wish to keep the seventh-day Sabbath that this passage teaches that the Sabbath was nailed to the cross and that, therefore, Sabbath-keeping is no longer binding upon Christians. . .

-Associate Book Editor, Review and Herald Publishing Association, at the time this article was written

THE objection is sometimes raised by those who do not wish to keep the seventh-day Sabbath that this passage teaches that the Sabbath was nailed to the cross and that, therefore, Sabbath-keeping is no longer binding upon Christians.

Let us examine Colossians 2:14-17 in the light of the Scriptures to determine whether there is any validity to the objection.

What is the "handwriting of ordinances?" 2 Chronicles 33:8 says that the "ordinances" were "commanded ... by the hand of Moses." The entire passage reads as follows:

Neither will I any more remove the foot of Israel from out of the land which I have appointed for your fathers; so that they will take heed to do all that I have commanded them, according to the whole law and the statutes and the ordinances by the hand of Moses.

Observe that a distinction seems to be made between what God commanded and what Moses commanded. This distinction is placed beyond question in 2 Kings 21:8 —a passage parallel to 2 Chronicles 33:8— which reads thus:

Neither will I make the feet of Israel move any more out of the land which I gave their fathers; only if they will observe to do according to all that I have commanded them, and according to all the law that my servant Moses commanded them.

Joshua 1:7, 8 indicates that "all the law, which Moses . . . commanded [Israel, verse 2]" was written in a "book," called "this book of the law." Deuteronomy 31:25, 26 refers to "this book of the law" and declares that Moses ordered that it be put "in the side of the ark . . . that it may be there for a witness against thee," that is, against Israel.

It is in the sense that Moses' book of the law was a "witness against" Israel, that "the handwriting of ordinances" is said to be "against us." In other words, should Israel depart from the ordinances of the Mosaic law, that law would stand as a witness against their apostasy.

It is clear that Moses commanded the handwriting of ordinances. But what did God command? Deuteronomy -1:13 says:

And he declared unto you his covenant, -which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments; and he wrote them upon two tables of stone.

These commandments, "written with the finger of God," were "written according to all the words which the Lord spake ... in the mount" (chap. 9:10). Having spoken the words of the Ten Commandments, chapter 5:22 declares that God "added no more"—not even the handwriting of ordinances. These two tables of stone containing the Ten Commandments, and written by God Himself, were placed "in the ark" (chap. 10:5).

The distinction between these two laws is unmistakable: The law Moses commanded, which he wrote in a book, and which contained the ordinances, was placed "in the side of the ark"; but the law God commanded, the Ten Commandments, which He wrote on tables of stone, was placed "in the ark." The former—"the law of commandments contained in ordinances"—was "abolished" (Eph. 2:15), when it was nailed to the cross; the latter— God's Ten Commandment law—was not nailed to the cross. Because it was not, it remains in force, and is therefore binding upon Christians today.

Why was the handwriting of ordinances abolished at the cross? It was abolished for two reasons: First, the types contained in the Mosaic ordinances met antitype when Christ died on the cross. Thus, there was no longer any need for God's people to observe the ordinance that commanded the killing of a lamb for a sin offering after Jesus died, because "the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world" (John 1:29) had been slain. Second, Satan, taking advantage of the Jewish tend ency to be exclusive, made the ordinances of Moses, which were designed to instruct both Jew and Gentile concerning the coming Redeemer, a means of separating them. Having accomplished this purpose, Satan induced the Jews to add burdensome rules and regulations to the Mosaic ordinances until they became a "yoke" that neither the Jewish "fathers" nor their descendants "were able to bear" (Acts 15:10). It is in this sense that Paul declares that the hand writing of ordinances "was contrary to us" (Col. 2:14). But Christ came and died on the cross, and in so doing He fulfilled the types of the Mosaic ordinances. Having been fulfilled, they were abolished. In the same act Christ triumphed over the "principalities and powers" of evil (see Eph. 6:12) who were determined to keep the Gentiles ignorant of God's plan of salvation.

Since the types contained in the Mosaic ordinances met antitype in Christ's redemptive work, Paul declares under inspiration that no one was to "judge" Christians "in meat [offerings], in drink [offerings] (Lev. 23:37), or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days" (Col. 2:16).

If one were to stop with verse 16 of Colossians 2, there might be some justification for thinking that Paul was referring to the seventh-day Sabbath, when he speaks of "the sabbath days," or simply "sabbaths." However, verse 17 clearly states that these sabbaths, or sabbath days, were "a shadow of things to come; but the body [the object casting the shadow] is of Christ." As a shadow ends when it meets the object casting it, so the various ordinances, such as, meat and drink offerings, holydays, new moons, and sabbaths that foreshadowed Christ's redemptive work, ended when type met antitype.

Does the Bible clearly distinguish be tween the sabbaths, which foreshadowed Christ's redemptive work, and the seventh day Sabbath of the fourth commandment? It does. Leviticus 23:24 says, for instance, that "the first day of the [seventh] month" was "a sabbath." Observe that it is not the Sabbath, but a sabbath. Similarly, "the tenth day of this seventh month"—"day of atonement" (chap. 23:27)—was declared to be "a sabbath" (verse 32). Observe that both of these sabbaths could not possibly be seventh-day sabbaths, since they fell on days more than a week apart. Like our birthdays, these typical sabbaths fell on all the days of the week in a course of years. Not so the seventh-day Sabbath. It was not linked to the month, but to the weekly cycle. But the important thing is that chapter 23:37, 38 states that all of the "holy convocations," with their "meat offering," and "drink offerings," were "beside the sabbaths of the Lord."

Which sabbath is the Sabbath of the Lord? Exodus 20:10 declares that "the seventh day is the sabbath of the Lord." Did this Sabbath point forward to Christ's redemptive work? No, it points back to Christ's creative work in the beginning. (Compare Ex. 20:8-11 and Eph. 3:9.)

Again the distinction is unmistakable: The typical sabbaths of the Mosaic ordinances pointed forward to Christ's redemptive work; the seventh-day Sabbath of the fourth commandment points back to Christ's creative work.

Conclusion: The objection that Colossians 2:14-17 teaches that the seventh-day Sabbath was nailed to the cross does not appear to be valid in the light of the Scriptures. The seventh-day is still "the sabbath of the Lord thy God," and hence, is still binding upon Christians.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-Associate Book Editor, Review and Herald Publishing Association, at the time this article was written

December 1971

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Apples of Gold in Baskets of Silver

New words seem to be capturing the minds of men and women every day. Every new dictionary is bulging with words not used or understood fifty years ago, yes, even ten years ago. . .

Futility or Utility?

NEWSWEEK recently reported a study of the American clergy made by Notre Dame sociologist John Koval which estimates that one in four U.S. Roman Catholic priests is ready to forsake his vows and one out of every eight Protestant ministers is seriously thinking of resigning his pastorate. . .

No Man Has Ever Converted a Soul

NOT long ago I sat with many others listening to one of our ministers trying to inspire the audience with his message. Although he was a very good man, well liked and highly respected by young and old as a Christian, somehow he did not succeed in communicating very well. The response was meager. He tried very hard, and perhaps that was his difficulty. . .

Good Listening is Enlightening

CAREFULLY cultivating the practice of good listening—really paying attention to what is being said, no matter who is saying it—is one of the best shortcuts for a church leader who seeks to accumulate current information that is pertinent. It has been repeatedly demonstrated that persons in leadership positions often are poor listeners, largely for these reasons. . .

Phaseout or Emphasis

ISN'T the Bible work gradually being phased out?" This question was recently asked of a conference Bible instructor by a layman of the church. . .

Does a Seventh-day Adventist minister have a Health Obligation?

THE Adventist minister has in his possession a wonderful gift—a gift that the Jewish people once treasured greatly. What is this gift? The health laws given to Moses by God and the health reform message as given to Ellen G. White. . .

Three Angels' Messages Personal and National

IT DOESN'T matter whether you are spraying roses, taking medicine, or exterminating termites, if the instruction on the label advises, REPEAT TREATMENT, you cannot blame anyone but yourself for the mediocre results you will get if you neglect to follow this direction. . .

The Spirit of Prophecy

WRITING on the Spirit of Prophecy and its continuing influence as God's guiding gift to the church, Elder W. A. Spicer in his excellent and enlightening book, Certainties of the Advent Movement, page 227, makes the following statement of assurance: "The gift still speaks its messages, its counsels covering even future times, and out lining experiences yet to come before the movement reaches the Land of Promise. . ."

The Undershepherds

THE pastor is the shepherd of the flock, the local elder the undershepherd. Together they have the responsibility of caring for the sheep. On the Sabbath day they help to provide proper spiritual nourishment, inspiration, and encouragement through Bible study, worship, and fellowship. The Sabbath should be a high experience for every Seventh-day Adventist Christian. . .

Hastening the Day of the Lord

"You should look forward to that day and hurry it along."

This is Life!

NO ONE—not even a tightrope walker, whom I would think knows all about exciting experiences—could say that life in the mission field is dull. . .

Is There a Way to Control Costs and Morals in Denominational Schools?

EDUCATORS, lend me your ears! There is no doubt that today an ever-lessening commitment to Christian education is found on the part of church leaders and church members of all denominations. Both leaders and laity have ceased to promote the principles of Christian education with the vigor exercised only a few years ago.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)