Answering Questions Concerning Radiocarbon Dating

ARGUMENTS against the historical authenticity of the book of Genesis appear with increasing frequency. Because radiocarbon dating is used in many of these arguments, those who are endeavoring to proclaim the everlasting gospel depicted in Revelation 14: 6-12 should understand this dating technique. . .

-President of Union College, Lincoln, Nebraska at the time this article was written

ARGUMENTS against the historical authenticity of the book of Genesis appear with increasing frequency. Because radiocarbon dating is used in many of these arguments, those who are endeavoring to proclaim the everlasting gospel depicted in Revelation 14: 6-12 should understand this dating technique.

The radiocarbon "age" of an object is determined by relating its level of radiocarbon to a standard of carbon-14 activity supplied by the U.S. National Bureau of Standards. The greater the ratio, the more recent the specimen; the smaller the ratio, the older the specimen.

As long as a plant or animal lives, it ingests radioactive carbon, which has been created by cosmicray bombardment in the earth's upper atmosphere, oxidized to carbon dioxide, and mixed throughout the atmosphere and in the water. Death of the plant or animal terminates this process. Since radioactive carbon is unstable, it converts to nitrogen but at a rate slow enough to be useful in measuring objects of antiquity.

A radiocarbon date is, in the strictest meaning, A.D. 1950 minus a radiocarbon age. For example, a radiocarbon age of 4000 corresponds to a 2051 B.C. radiocarbon date (A.D. 1950-4000=2051 B.C.). Common usage often makes no distinction between the terms radiocarbon date and radiocarbon age.

A radiocarbon age is the usual way of reporting a measurement of the relative amount of radioactive carbon (carbon with isotope weight 14) in a specimen with a chemical composition that includes carbon. Measurements made at various laboratories throughout the world have determined that within 5,730 years half an initial amount of carbon-14 will have spontaneously transformed to nitrogen. This carbon14 half-life measurement of 5,730 years is precise to within less than one hundred years. Measurements of radioactive carbon con tent in specimens of historical interest are reported in.terms of the time that would be required for radiocarbon activity characteristic of the carbon dioxide in Earth's atmosphere during recent time to diminish to the level exhibited by the specimen. 1 Given the assumptions upon which this procedure is based, any carefully determined radiocarbon age is correct, for it is actually a report of a contemporary situation.

Interpreting Radiocarbon Age

An interpretation of a radiocarbon age in terms of real time (or of a radiocarbon date in terms of an actual calendar date) may be speculative, for the amount of radioactive carbon in a given specimen depends on two factors (1) The amount of time that has elapsed since the specimen ceased to exchange carbon with its surroundings (died), and (2) the concentration of radioactive carbon that the specimen contained when carbon exchange ceased. Knowledge of one of these factors is necessary for conversion of a radiocarbon age measurement into a determination of the other. Remains of a plant or animal that derived its carbon from the atmosphere at a time when the ratio of carbon-14 to carbon- 12 was the same as has been characteristic of recent time would have a radiocarbon age equal to the time since death of the organism that furnished the remains (assuming there has been no subsequent contamination with carbon from a different period of time). No certain real time interpretation of a radiocarbon age can be made without knowledge of the carbon-14 concentration that characterized the specimen at the time it ceased to maintain equilibrium with the carbon in its environment.

The maximum sensitivity of present means for detecting car bon-14 corresponds to a radio carbon age between 40,000 and 50,000. Anthracite coal, gas, and oil from deep wells, as well as shells, bones, and fragments of vegetation from the deeper portions of the sedimentary column, have been found to contain no detectable amount of carbon-14. Such materials are described as of infinite radiocarbon age. The radiocarbon dating literature contains a large number of references to plant and animal remains that have radiocarbon ages in every portion of the range between zero (contemporary) and infinite (greater than about 50,000).

If a person assumes a one-to-one correspondence between real time and radiocarbon ages in excess of 4500, he finds his datato be in contradiction to the inferences concerning time based on the eleventh chapter of Genesis and supported in the testimony of Ellen G. White. According to the Masoretic text for Genesis 5 and 11, one would not expect this planet to contain plant or animal remains older than about 6,000 years of real time. The Septuagint extends this period to about 7,500 years. One must presume either that the eleventh chapter of Genesis has little historical validity other than a selected listing of prominent men who lived over a period of time exceeding 40,000 years, or that radiocarbon ages in excess of 3,500 to 4,000 describe initial radioactive characteristics rather than a lapse of time. According to the latter viewpoint the Flood came at the end of a period during which Earth's biosphere contained less than 1/300th as much carbon- 14 in proportion to carbon-12 as has been characteristic over the past 3,000 years.

The Earlier Periods

Radiocarbon age has been firmly correlated with real time over the past 3,000 years by means of wood fiber that has been dated by dendrochronological techniques (study of growth rings) and by specimens to which a firm historical age can be assigned. For times earlier than 1000 B.C. correlation becomes increasingly uncertain. Radiocarbon dates for ancient Egyptian material are younger than those that are generally accepted by archeologists, the discrepancy ranging from about 250 years for the time of Ramses II (c. 1200 B.C.) to about 600 years for the first dynasty (generally considered c. 3000 B.C.).2 A chronology of Bristlecone Pine growth striations has been developed that extends to 5300 B.C., but the radiocarbon age for the oldest dendrochronological dated Bristlecone Pine fiber is about 1,000 "years" less. 3

The conclusions of archeologists and Bristlecone Pine dendrochronologists require a decreasing carbon-14 concentration in the atmosphere between 6000 B.C. and 1000 B.C. The limitations imposed by Genesis 11 and Ellen G. White comments require that the available radio carbon ages be interpreted to indicate an increasing carbon-14 concentration between the Flood and the latter part of the second millennium B.C.

One can suggest that dendrochronologists are unacquainted with Bristlecone Pine growth characteristics that may have existed during the first millennium following the Flood, and that both dendrochronologists and archeologists have been influenced by the prevailing attitudes concerning evolutionary development over long periods of time. In an article that will soon be published in the Signs of the Times the author presents evidence for an increase in the relative radiocarbon content of the atmosphere during the period between the Flood and the middle of the second millennium B.C.


Footnotes

1. R. H. Brown, "Radiocarbon Dating," in H. G. Coffin, ed., Creation Accident or Design? (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald Publishing Association, 1969), pp. 299-316.

2. T. Save-Soderberg and I. U. Olsson, "C-14 Dating and Egyptian Chronology," in I. U. Olsson, ed., Radiocarbon Variations and Absolute Chronology (New York: Wiley interscience Division, 1970), pp. 35-53.

3. D. W. Ferguson, "Dendrochronology of Bristlecone Pine, pinus aristata," in Olsson, ed., Radiocarbon Variations and Absolute Chronology, pp. 237-259.

Advertisement - Ministry in Motion 300x250

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-President of Union College, Lincoln, Nebraska at the time this article was written

April 1973

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

New Approaches to an Old Concept

THE SANITARIUM idea is definitely not outdated, although the term may be. This month's health section focuses on some of the current attempts being made by Adventist hospitals, medical groups, and individual practitioners in applying to modern medical practice the instruction the Lord has given to us concerning the sanitarium work. . .

Check Up On Your Church

There are guides to good hotels, good restaurants, and what have you. Now, according to Religious News Service, the Roman Catholics of London have published the Good Church Guide. . .

How to Meet Temptations

An address delivered to the Swiss Conference and European Missionary Council in Basel, Switzerland, Sept. 23, 1885.

How to Save Time in the Ministry (Part 1)

A MINISTER once polled his congregation through a questionnaire to discover how much time they felt he should be spending each week on various activities: sermon preparation, administration, counseling, committee and board meetings, church and prayer meetings, youth activities, pastoral visitation, shut-in visitation, and community activities. . .

Six Steps to a Successful Visitation Program

A SIMPLE and workable plan for visitation for Seventh-day Adventist pastors and evangelists is a must. Needless hours are often wasted prior to public evangelistic meetings in organizing the names that are hopefully interests, not to mention the loss of needed contact during the development of the interest. Also, the local pastors often labor under many self-styled types of visitation programs that are often of little help to the next pastor. In turn, the new pastor spends much time and labor setting up what seems to be a better organization. . .

Crusade Pilot Project Report

Witnessing + Follow-up + Bible Studies = Crusade Results

It Is Time to Finish Our Work

THOMAS CARLYLE, the English essayist and historian, once attended a New Year's Eve party at a home in Northern England. Late in the evening he became bored with the trite, idle talk and quietly slipped out into the dark night and walked to the seashore. . .

He Delivers Them Out of Their Distresses

Editorial Note: This is a suggestive sermon outline to be used with the May 12 Disaster and Famine Relief Offering. . .

The Trespass Offering

EVERY offering was ordained to aid man's understanding of salvation. "God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have ever lasting life" (John 3:16). The offering of Christ our Saviour was the ultimate in offerings, swinging the gate of salvation wide open. All other offerings culminated in this one. . .

404 Trophies in Montego Bay

C. D. BROOKS, field secretary of the General Conference, was invited to conduct a series of meetings in Montego Bay, Jamaica, in connection with the Inter-American Division mammoth evangelistic thrust during the fiftieth year of the division's organization. . .

Listen to the Man!

The congregation faced a serious financial dilemma. The members, old and young, knew that something had to be done to meet the emergency. They knew they needed a workable plan that the larger part of the congregation would accept and work to implement. All looked to the pastor for leadership. . .

What Is Good Music?

MANY times parents are led to commit them selves for or against something, and then find out that there are strong arguments against the position that they have taken. We frequently face this problem in connection with radio and TV programs or certain musical selections. Because few things in this life do not have some good in them, the categorization of, for example, a musical number into a "good" or a "wicked" number may be treacherous because of various aspects involved. . .

Drawing Lessons From Sacred History

THERE are two chapters in the Bible of which the Lord's messenger declares, "I urge that these chapters be read at least once every week." --Testimonies to Ministers, p. 98. Notice that Mrs. White does not suggest that they be read, but urges it. And she is not content to say that they should be read once a week, but at least once every week. . .

A Conditioning Center- "The Sanitarium Idea"?

OUR sanitariums are to be an instrumentality for reaching the people, an agency for showing them the evil of disregarding the laws of life and health, and for teaching them how to preserve the body in the best condition. Sanitariums . . . are to be centers from which a work of healing, restoring, and educating shall be carried on." --Counsels on Health, p. 207.

Have You Remembered?

RECENTLY a question was put to me that has caused me to do considerable thinking, studying, and also some heart searching. In fact, it has caused me more than a little concern, so I would like to share it with you. . .

Man's Works and the Latter Rain

PREOCCUPATION with the glory and miracle-working power of the latter rain prevents its fall and unfits us to stand through the fearful, subsequent time of trouble. Effectual prayer for God's Spirit must accompany a determination to discover and remedy the cause for His delay. This requires a clear conception of what Cod intends to accomplish, and how. "It is the darkness of misapprehension of God that is enshrouding the world," says Christ's messenger, and adds, "The last rays of merciful light, the last message of mercy to be given to the world, is a revelation of His character of love." 1 Thus, not power but character, the glory of which God desires to display, should occupy our attention.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)