The Prophetic Jigsaw

MISINTERPRETATION of prophecy has plagued the Christian church from its inception. John 21:20-23 mentions that Jesus revealed to Peter a glimmering of his fate. Peter, eager to know how John also would fare, asked, "What shall this man do?" Jesus replied, "If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?"

-president and treasurer of the Papuan Culf Mission, Australasian Division at the time his article was written

MISINTERPRETATION of prophecy has plagued the Christian church from its inception. John 21:20-23 mentions that Jesus revealed to Peter a glimmering of his fate. Peter, eager to know how John also would fare, asked, "What shall this man do?" Jesus replied, "If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?"

Peter reported the statement to the brethren and they, knowing that Jesus never spoke lightly, that His every statement was fraught with truth, immediately speculated on His saying.

If John was to tarry till Jesus came, they reasoned, then that would mean that he wouldn't die, for he would be translated with out seeing death. You can almost imagine the early evangelists hammering out the conclusion point by point from the evangelistic platform. Time lent force to their interpretation as one by one each of the apostles except John, lay down his life for the sake of the gospel. James was the first to fall by the sword, and the time came when, according to Christ's prediction, Peter died also. But John seemed to be immortal. Not even immersion in a cauldron of boiling oil could thwart the prediction's fulfillment.

If you had been living then, wouldn't you have been tempted to proclaim the imminence of Christ's second advent on the basis of these facts? I would. I would find it almost impossible to resist. "Yet Jesus said not unto him, He shall not die; but, If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?"

In the third year of the reign of the Emperor Trajan the church was perplexed and her critics rejoiced when the apostle John, at the grand old age of nearly 100 years, quietly passed to his rest. Did Christ's prophecy fail? Not one whit. What did fail was the interpretation placed upon it by the early church.

Sacred history reveals that John did tarry until Christ appeared. (See The Acts of the Apostles, p. 582. The prediction Jesus made of John should be considered in the same light as His prediction in Matthew 16:28.)

The Purpose of Prophecy

The primary purpose of prophecy is not to make us wise before the event but to give us confidence in God and His control of the event. Jesus said, I tell you these things now, that when they come to pass, you may believe (see John 14:29).

It is our duty, not to play the part of the prophet, but to store our minds with the facts of the prophecy so that when they are fulfilled by history our faith also will be fulfilled. The prophecies of the Bible are like the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle and only history can piece them together accurately. If we try to fit the puzzle together prematurely we may get a distorted picture.

It is not harmful to speculate on prophecy, in fact it is to be com mended. But don't fall into the trap of setting forth your speculation as fact. We humans like to have all our information in concrete form with every detail pigeonholed in its correct compartment, but with unfulfilled prophecy we cannot do this. The details should be kept fluid until they are set by history. If we set them according to our preconceived opinions we may make some embarrassing errors as we have done in the past.

Remember the "Eastern question"? Some refused to acknowledge that it was a question and presented the Turkey-Russia conflict as the answer, much to their, and our, embarrassment.

James White's caution regarding the interpretation of unfulfilled prophecy given in 1877 is still good counsel today:

"In exposition of unfulfilled prophecy, where the history is not written, the student should put forth his propositions with not too much positiveness, lest he find himself straying in the field of fancy.

"There are those who think more of future truth than of present truth. They see but little light in the path in which they walk, but think they see great light ahead of them.

"Positions taken upon the Eastern question are based upon prophecies which have not yet met their fulfillment. Here we should tread lightly, and take positions carefully, lest we be found removing the landmarks fully established in the advent movement. It may be said that there is a general agreement upon this subject, and that all eyes are turned toward the war now in progress between Turkey and Russia as the fulfillment of that portion of prophecy which will give great confirmation of faith in the soon loud cry and close of our message. But what will be the result of this positiveness in unfulfilled prophecies should things not come out as very confidently expected, is an anxious question." Quoted in The SDA Bible Commentary, on Dan. 11:45.

A United Europe?

One prophecy that we have often used to "prove" that Europe will never be united is the dream image of Daniel 2. The Lord graciously preserved us from humiliation during World War II when He halted the unity of Eu rope at the Anglo-Saxon border, but He may not do it again. Note that the prophecy does not say that the nations of Europe will not come together. It says they will not cleave together. Our under standing of just what degree of international cooperation is precluded by this word is perhaps not complete. As we are now living on the eve of a possible united Europe let us be careful not to add to the words of the Lord. Revelation 17, which amplifies Daniel 2, does speak of ten kings who give their power to the beast for a short time. They may come together, but the prophecy concludes that they will not cleave together.

We must be very careful not to read into a prophecy that which is not there. When speaking or writing about unfulfilled prophecy we should use the words, "may," "might," and "perhaps," rather than "will," "shall," and "definitely." In these critical times dogmatic assertions founded on mere probability are entirely out of place.

If we feed God's people on one error, it means that on that point we are starving them of the truth. Be careful what you say and write concerning unfulfilled prophecy, because we can't afford to spend another hundred years sifting through the sensational speculations of this generation.

We can speak with greater certainty on those areas of prophecy that have been amplified by the writings of Ellen G. White, but as for the remainder, "patience is a virtue." Unfulfilled prophecy is like a field of immature grain. It's almost impossible to tell the wheat from the tares. What we may believe to be good wheat may turn out to be nothing but tares. Only when the harvest is ripe will we be able to see things as they really are.

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-president and treasurer of the Papuan Culf Mission, Australasian Division at the time his article was written

February 1974

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

A Holy, Healthy, Happy People

"IT WAS not the will of God that the coming of Christ should be thus delayed. God did not design that His people, Israel, should wander forty years in the wilderness. He promised to lead them directly to the land of Canaan, and establish them there a holy, healthy, happy people. But those to whom it was first preached, went not in 'because of unbelief.' Their hearts were filled with murmuring, rebellion, and hatred, and He could not fulfill His covenant with them. . .

Revival and That Agenda

The fourth business session of the now historic annual council of 1973 was called to order at 9:30 on the morning of October 9 by Neal C. Wilson, vice-president of the General Conference for the North American Division. But before plunging into the heavy agenda, crowded with numerous items, the chairman expressed appreciation for the morning devotional message. . .

Where Did Moses Get it?

AN INFIDEL lawyer had been told by his physician that a fatal disease had fastened itself upon him and that recovery was impossible. With death staring him in the face, the lawyer went to a friend of his, who was a Christian, and asked for instruction in the Christian religion. The friend urged him to get a Bible and to study it, patiently and sympathetically, as he would his law books. . .

God's Priorities

A QUESTION frequently asked me, especially when I am with young people, is, "What is your work? What is involved in it?" In replying to this question I usually explain about the committees and boards, the personnel problems, the financial problems, the approving and adopting of building plans, the study of administrative policies for the various fields, the days we spend on occasions studying the wage scale, and our dealings with government agencies. . .

War, Worship, and Worlds End

THE first "battle" in this world, the first shedding of human blood, was over the issue of worship. It transpired at the very gates of Eden when one brother slew the other. "And wherefore slew he him? Because his own works were evil, arid his brother's righteous" (1 John 3:12). But of more interest to us probably is the fact that the last battle of earth is also to be over the manner of worship. History begins and ends with religious conflict. . .

The Time of the "Times of Refreshing"

"REPENT ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord; and he shall send Jesus Christ, which be fore was preached unto you: whom the heaven must receive until the times of restitution of all things, which God hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began" (Acts 3:19-21).


WHEN Paul wrote his first letter to the church in Corinth, he included among his words of greeting this unique expression: "The testimony of Christ was confirmed in you.". . .

The Need for Doctrinal Preaching

THERE is too much prejudice against doctrine in our day, especially against doctrinal preaching. Some hold that doctrines are too obscure, too difficult to explain to the lay mind, and that, since there are so many different opinions, such discussions and sermons result in confusion rather than knowledge. Sadly, some have gone so far as to claim it does not matter what a man believes so long as he behaves himself and attends church. . .

Pathfinders After 25 Years

I FIRST came face to face with the wonderful world of Pathfindering fifteen years ago as a young pastor located in a small community several hundred miles from the conference office, ministering to a small congregation. . .

The Work of the Heshbon Survey Team, 1973

ONE of the aims of this past season's excavation at Heshbon was to gain an archeological picture of occupational sites in the vicinity of Tell Hesban, with special emphasis on thoroughly ex ploring the very large valley, Wadi Hesban, which lies to the north and west of the Tell. A small survey team of four was assembled to accomplish this task and, in addition, to attempt to solve the problem of tracing a Roman road known to have ascended from Livias (modern Tell er-Rameh) in the Jordan Valley to Esbus (the Latin designation for Biblical Heshbon). . .

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)