Grant, Treaty, and Covenant

RECENT emphasis by Old Testament theologians on the covenant theme has brought to light much helpful and interesting material from extra- Biblical sources that helps us better understand the Old Testament covenant emphasis. . .

-professor of religion at Inca Union College, wrote this article while studying at Andrews University.

RECENT emphasis by Old Testament theologians on the covenant theme has brought to light much helpful and interesting material from extra- Biblical sources that helps us better understand the Old Testament covenant emphasis. Some theologians, such as Walther Eichrodt,1 have gone to the extreme of building a whole theology around the centrality of the covenant tradition to Biblical revelation. Eichrodt has considered the covenant as the unique unifying theme that binds the Old Testament with the New. But this would impose too great a limit upon the infinite variety of the Old Testament teachings. It is probably more accurate to view the covenant as one of the central unifying themes.

The covenant is a very ancient institution practiced by many nations under a variety of forms and applications. Some covenants, for ex ample, were made between equals, others between king and subject, but never in extra-Biblical sources do we find a covenant being made by a pagan god with one of his worshipers or with an entire nation. Only in Scripture do we find the Deity making a covenant with His subjects.

Nevertheless, the Biblical covenants do follow the customary and traditional forms of the times. This can be seen very clearly by comparison with extant Near-Eastern texts. One of the first known uses of covenant in non-Biblical sources is found in the Qatna documents.2 Two of fifteen cuneiform tablets bear the title TAR-biritu, the latter part of the term being the Akkadian cognate expression for the Hebrew covenant term berith.

The first of these two tablets contains a list of personal names of certain individuals who have agreed to enter by compact or covenant into another's service and to fulfill certain obligations. The second is a ration list and illustrates the nature of the covenant by naming certain specific rations the men were to receive in return for their services.

The interesting thing about these documents is that, according to Albright, they are to be dated not later than the fourteenth century B.C., which shows that the covenant tradition is very ancient. This evidence would seem to indicate that the Biblical idea of covenant is not to be isolated from the practices of other peoples from earliest times.

Then, too, there are the Hittite suzerain-vassal treaties. Some have tried to show that the Ten Commandments reveal this form, where the suzerain or lord makes a treaty or covenant with his vassal or lesser subject. Mendenhall has been one of the main proponents of the Ten Commandment theory, but the main problem is that the commandments do not harmonize exactly with the treaty format, which is divided into the six items listed below:

1. The preamble

2. The historical prologue

3. Stipulations concerning future relations

4. Regulations concerning the deposit of the agreement in the temple

5. Invocation of the gods as witnesses

6. Curses and blessings

It is possible that the Ten Commandments might conform to the first three conditions, but they themselves do not contain the last three (though it can be argued that the service in which they were accepted, might). The unique difference between the two institutions is to be found in the fact that the commandments were given by God and that Scripture uses the word covenant when speaking of them (Deut. 4:13). But there is no record of a suzerain-vassal treaty having been made by a Hittite god. We would expect that God in making His covenant with Israel would con descend to employ known tradition as far as possible in order to make His message meaningful and to present a new relationship implying certain well-defined obligations. But in this case it would not be possible to follow completely the treaty outline.

On the other hand, it is interesting to note that the book of Deuteronomy, a series of sermons delivered by Moses on the border of Canaan shortly before his death, follows the six-term Hittite treaty form. It is possible that Moses and the people of Israel could have known of this covenant tradition from commercial contacts between the Hittites and the Egyptians. On the basis of this parallel some scholars would now want to date the book of Deuteronomy well before the year 1,000 B.C. as against the later date in the time of the Prophets proposed by the adherents to the Documentary hypothesis.

But the most interesting confirmation of the covenant tradition from extra-Biblical sources comes from the time of Abraham. Well in advance of many of these fascinating discoveries, Ellen White had stated concerning the Abrahamic covenant that "the Lord condescended to enter into a covenant with His servant, employing such forms as were customary among men for the ratification of a solemn engagement." 3 When she penned these words there was no way of checking her statement from extra-Biblical sources, but such is not the case today. What she wrote many years ago has been recently confirmed by the discovery of the Surpu documents in the Akkadian language.

Weinfeld, of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, in an article entitled: "The Covenant of Grant in the Old Testament and in the Ancient Near East," and in a lexical entry in a theological dictionary in German, has brought to light some valuable information, especially concerning the Abrahamic covenant.4 He points out that the Abrahamic covenant is a promissory type covenant as op posed to the obligatory Sinaitic type covenant, which is in the form of a suzerain-vassal treaty. However, it is probably more accurate to suggest that we can see both types in both covenants.

Weinfeld points out that it was customary for persons in authority to make a gift of land and dynasty to subjects who had shown loyalty and obedience. God employs this tradition in the Abrahamic promises of Genesis 15 and 17. The grant was always given without reference to merit and to protect the rights of the servant. This helps us to under stand the meaning of the everlasting covenant by means of which God offers us the new earth and a position as kings with Christ on the basis of fidelity to the covenant terms.

Weinfeld presents yet other aspects of the covenant of grant well known to ancient civilizations, such as adoption, election, et cetera, but one other reference must suffice. The divine covenant made with Abraham, as recorded in Genesis 15, was accompanied by an oath, a smoking oven and a blazing torch (Gen. 15:17). "In the Surpu documents we read about an oath taken by holding a torch, or about the oath of furnace, stove, et cetera." 5 In other words here we have the extra-Biblical evidence confirming what Ellen White had said many years before the discovery.


FOOTNOTES

1. Walther Eichrodt, Theology of the Old Testament, vol. 1, trans. by J. A. Baker (Philadelphia-. Westminster Press, 1961).

2. W. F. Albright, "The Hebrew Expression for 'Making a Covenant' in the Pre-lsraelite Documents," Bulletin of American Schools of Oriental Research, CXXI (1951), pp. 21, 22.

3. Ellen G. White, Patriarchs and Prophets (Pacific Press, 1913), p. 137.

4. M. Weinfeld, "The Covenant of Grant in the Ancient Near East," Journal of the American Oriental Society, XC (1970), pp. 184-203; G. ). Botterweck and Helmer Ringren, gen. eds., Theologisches Worterbuch zum Alten Testament, Berith, by M. Weinfeld (Stuttgart: Verlag W. Kohlhammer, 1972), pp. 781-808.

5. Weinfeld, "Covenant of Grant," JAOS, XC, p. 196.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-professor of religion at Inca Union College, wrote this article while studying at Andrews University.

July 1974

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Ellen G. White and Competitive Sports

WE DON'T have any record of the wins and losses of the Battle Creek College Bruisers or what ever they called their football team. Neither do we know who won the boxing matches in the basement of the college building. But Ellen G. White's statements in relation to exercise and recreational activity are clear enough without these backgrounds. . .

"Schools of Brutality"

A REPORT of the 1973 Indianapolis 500 mile auto race in the June 11, 1973, issue of Time, mentions that it is the world's largest, richest, and costliest racing event of its kind. The story went on to say: "One rationale for the Indy has been that it encourages innovations in auto design, especially in safety devices. . .

"Peter in the New Testament"

THAT THE PAPACY is "the great est obstacle on the road to Ecumenism" was acknowledged by Pope Paul VI in an address to the Secretariat for Promoting Christian Unity on April 28, 1967. Yet several of the bilateral consultations in which the Roman Catholic Church is currently engaged have built up enough confidence to take on the most difficult question of the role of the Papacy in a reunited Christian church. . .

What a Layman Expects of His Pastor

THE church, as a congregation, does not always remember that its pastor is also a human being. The Scriptures make a point of the fact that each year in the sanctuary ceremony the high priest offered a lamb as an atonement for himself and his family before he ministered for the people. He was subject to the same weaknesses as those for whom he interceded. . .

The Lion Tamer

THE story of Daniel in the lions' den is too often put into the same category as Aesop's fables or the tales of Hans Anderson. To perceive its real intent, however, is to recognize that the story has a depth of daily relevance for every Christian and that it carries a special message for the church as a whole in the last generation of history. . .

The Role of Rhythm in Church Music (Part 2)

HOW then shall we address ourselves to the very vital issue of rhythm in the church today? Certainly to try to dismiss or overlook the problem as irrelevant is only a vain attempt to side-step what is becoming an increasingly burning question. Assuredly no one can claim to have all the answers to the complex situation of our present time. But there are a number of approaches that might merit our consideration that at least might stimulate our thinking and provide a base for further study of this problem. . .

Commencement of the Cosmos

HAVE the various features of the universe existed from the endless eons of eternity, or was there a commencement of the cosmos as to time, space, and substance? The initial emergence of the universe is one of the quandaries of cosmogonists. . .

Lady in a Yellow Smock

CAN Seventh-day Adventist medical institutions approximate and even surpass the level of care given by non-Adventist facilities and yet largely miss the fundamental reason for their existence? Is it possible for patients to enter and leave our institutions virtually untouched by the health message that is to play such an important role in soul winning? It is in recognition of this danger that Simi Valley Adventist Hospital has implemented a dimension of heart-level concern and integrated it into their already high-quality program of care. Here's how it works. . .

The Vegetarian Advantage

Today, more than ever before, we can reply with scientific reasons. As you keep several of these facts and figures in mind, you will find opportunity to share them with others. . .

Doctor-Minister Teamwork

SINCE there is a growing recognition among Adventist health and ministerial professionals that there needs to be closer cooperation and unity on a denomination-wide basis, an attempt was made during the 1972-1973 school year at Loma Linda to find out just how extensive this feeling is. Also, an effort was made to learn what problems might stand in the way of any movement toward increased unity. . .

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)