The Growth-Line Method of Age Dating

"The [Adventist] church recognizes that the creationist position faces some very difficult problems. . . . There is the problem of the age rings on clamshells. . . . on some fossil clams [these] seem to indicate that these clams were living on the earth 450 million years ago--just as the evolutionists insist they did."1 This quotation is from one of at least two articles 1, 2 in recent Adventist literature that have referred to clam growth rings as a difficult problem for creationists. What are these rings? How are they used in age dating? Are they a serious problem for those who accept the book of Genesis as historically accurate?

-assistant professor of biology, Graduate School, Loma Linda University at the time this article was written

"The [Adventist] church recognizes that the creationist position faces some very difficult problems. . . . There is the problem of the age rings on clamshells. . . . on some fossil clams [these] seem to indicate that these clams were living on the earth 450 million years ago--just as the evolutionists insist they did."1 This quotation is from one of at least two articles 1, 2 in recent Adventist literature that have referred to clam growth rings as a difficult problem for creationists. What are these rings? How are they used in age dating? Are they a serious problem for those who accept the book of Genesis as historically accurate?

In 1963 J. W. Wells of Cornell University first proposed age dating fossils by growth rings or growth lines.3 This new method (which will here be called the growth-line method) of age dating was important because it was apparently independent of the various radiometric time clock methods and because it could date a fossil directly. (Radiometric methods for older samples can usually date only certain rocks surrounding the fossils.) If the growth-line method gave fossil ages similar to those obtained by the radiometric clocks, it would definitely help establish the validity of the radiometric ages. The partial agreement of preliminary growth line age determinations with radiometric ages has caused some perplexity among those believing in the short Biblical chronology. Recent research, however, does not support its use as an independent age-dating method, as will be seen.

This article will describe how the growth-line method works, the problems in applying it to age dating, and how growth lines could provide scientific evidence in support of the Biblical Flood account.

Growth-Line Method

First, two concepts need explanation—periodic growth bands and tidal friction. Many living organisms produce periodic bands or lines as they grow. Growth lines found in coral skeletons, clam and brachiopod shells, fish earbones (otoliths), and certain algae (stromatolites) have possible use in age dating. The growth-line patterns in these organisms are considerably more complex than the more familiar features of tree rings.

The basic unit of these patterns consists of a dark band, high in organic (protein) content, and a lighter color band consisting mainly of mineral material (calcium carbonate) (see photo). This basic unit we will term an "approximately daily (circadian) band," although an organism may produce two or more of these basic units each day. Circadian bands usually vary from one ten thousandth to two thousandths of an inch in width. Longer, more complex, growth patterns are usually formed by periodic fluctuations in the width or nature of the circadian bands. Fortnightly, monthly, and annual patterns often occur in this way. These patterns are correlated with and are presumably a response of the organism to various physical environmental factors such as the light-dark cycle, tidal fluctuations, temperature, and sedimentation.

The second concept, tidal friction, requires sophisticated mathematics for a complete explanation, but the basic concept is quite simple. As the earth rotates, the moon raises tidal bulges on the earth. Due to friction, these bulges lag in time, causing the earth's rotation to slow down and the moon's motion to speed up. As a result the days have gradually lengthened and the number of days per month and days per year has gradually decreased.

Scientists estimate that the day length is growing longer at the rate of two thousandths of a second per century. They base this figure on the observed changes in the orbits of artificial satellites and comparison of actual with expected times of ancient eclipses or other astronomical events. 4 Although such a change seems insignificant and undetectable, it could be significant in some cases. For example, if the geologic (radiometric) time scale is accepted, 100 million years ago the day would have been 33 minutes shorter than the present day, giving 374 days per year. At 600 million years (the oldest radiometric dated material where well-defined fossils occur), the day would have been 3.3 hours shorter, giving 424 days per year.

With these figures in mind Wells proposed the growth-line method as an independent time clock. He3 suggested that if both daily and yearly bands could be identified in fossils, the fossil's age could be determined by counting the number of daily bands per yearly band. Thus (from our previous examples) a fossil containing 374 daily bands per yearly band would be 100 million years old, and one containing 424 daily bands per yearly band would be 600 million years old. Other ages could be calculated in the same way.

Using fossil coral specimens from the Devonian and Pennsylvanian geologic strata, Wells 3 counted respectively 385-410 and 385-390 daily bands per yearly band. From the radiometric dates assigned these strata, the expected number of daily bands would have been 399 and 392, respectively. The correlation was close. Approximately 360 daily bands per year of growth were counted in specimens of one re cent coral species living in the West Indies. Although interesting, Wells's data is inconclusive because of the small number of specimens used and the large range in values.

Most of the recent-work of this type has been done with clams, and results are expressed in terms of changes in days per month rather than days per year, since complete monthly sequences are more commonly preserved in the fossil record. While some of the growth-line ages that have been reported agree with the radiometric ages, these data contain two serious irregularities where the growth-line ages differ greatly from the radiometric ages. 5 These irregularities indicate that (1) the earth's rotation has not slowed down at a constant rate, (2) the radiometric ages are correct, or (3) insufficient data has been collected. C. Pannella, 5 formerly at Yale University, maintains that the differences are real (i.e., that sufficient data has been collected to verify that the irregularities do occur) and the radiometric ages are valid. He believes the irregularities indicate that the earth has not always slowed down at the same rate. 5

Problems With Method

The most serious problem in using the growth-line method concerns the amount and constancy of the slowing down of the earth's rotation. The ancient astronomical records, which offer historical evidence that the earth's rotation is slowing down at the rate of two thousandths of a second per century, are not easily interpreted. Some of these ancient records are definitely not reliable. R. R. Newton, of Johns Hopkins University, discusses this problem at some length. 4 The evidence seems to indicate that the earth's rotation has not slowed at a constant rate even within relatively recent historic time. Newton states that "ancient astronomical data show with high confidence that the amount of tidal friction ten centuries ago was twice what it is now." As far as I am aware no method exists for independently (i.e., independent from growth lines) determining the amount of tidal friction or slowing down prior to the ancient astronomical observations.

The growth-line data previously alluded to are interpreted as indicating a changing slowing down-rate, and geophysicists are, in fact, now using the growth-line data to establish this rate. How ever, if the growth-line data are used to calculate how the earth has slowed down, they cannot be used as an independent age-dating method, for this would involve circular reasoning. They could still be used in age dating by calibration with the radiometric ages, but then the independence between the two methods would be lost and the value of the method greatly reduced.

The data presently available on growth lines in recent living organisms is insufficient to properly evaluate their meaning in fossil species. It is not always simple to determine what is a daily, monthly, or yearly band. Subdaily bands often occur and may be confused with daily bands. Since growth lines are occasion ally missing, some researchers urge the use of maximum line counts rather than average counts. However, this can lead to unsure conclusions, since in one recent species anywhere from 283-425 circadian bands per yearly band have been found. 6

If such large ranges (283-425) are typical, large sample sizes (many fossils) would be required to get adequately precise averages for the method to be meaningful (i.e., the range of normal variation could be much larger than the change in the average to be expected over many millions of years). An adequate sample size is difficult to obtain because sufficiently well-preserved fossils are rare. Preservation of growth lines in fossils is often not good and the researcher can let his bias help interpret unclear growth patterns. Objective methods of identifying and counting these bands are not now available. Environmental factors change the nature of the lines in ways that we do not now completely understand. Some of these problems could disappear with future work. Others seem insurmountable.

Alternative Interpretations

The use of growth lines in age dating fossils does not seem feasible, and it has not been advanced as such in recent papers on the subject. 5 ' 6 ' 7 However, the growth lines might provide other types of useful information—particularly in the context of the Biblical Flood. For example, could the apparent changes in number of circadian lines per month or year provide information about antediluvian and flood conditions or events? Might they indicate an abrupt change in the earth's rotation during the Flood? Such change would be in harmony with the violent nature of the Flood as revealed in inspired writings. While the growth-line data are not at present easily interpreted in terms of an abrupt change, the irregularities that occur in the data do partially support it.

Different depths at which the antediluvian marine animals lived might also be a cause of variation in the number-of circadian lines per month and year. Depth is known to have an effect on the nature of the growth lines in re cent organisms—however, no data is presently available on the quantitative relationship between depth and number of lines. If valid, this explanation would fit H. W. Clark's8 interpretation of fossil distributions. He explains these in terms of the ecological distribution (e.g., depth) of organisms at the time of the Flood, rather than as the consequence of prolonged evolution.

Growth lines may also provide other information about the natural history or ecology of fossilized organisms (paleo-ecology) since they are often sensitive indicators of environmental conditions. Present research in this area is mainly concerned with gathering sufficient data on growth lines in living organisms to allow interpretation of fossil growth lines. It is suggested that such information as depth (previously alluded to) and temperature of water, age of the organism, and season of the year when death occurred may be reflected by the growth-line patterns. More importantly, by comparing the growth patterns of fossils within a bed of fossils, the fossil group might be determined as (1) a community with a catastrophic (flood) death (growth pat terns have the same endpoint), (2) a normal life-span community (overlapping growth patterns), or (3) no community, e.g., not in position of growth (no correlation between growth patterns). In a catastrophic explanation of the geologic record (as compared with a long time sequence explanation), the first and third cases should occur most frequently.

Conclusions

Relatively little work has been done with invertebrate growth lines; therefore caution should be used in saying just how they can or cannot be used. Present information does indicate, how ever, they will not be useful as an independent age-dating method. 5

As in so many instances where there is apparent conflict between science and revelation, more data or a careful analysis of the already available data suggests alternate interpretations. "True science and Inspiration are in perfect harmony." 9 The use of inspired testimony regarding the natural world enables the Christian scientist to reach greater understanding than would be possible from nature alone.

All problems regarding growth lines (or other aspects of science) should not be expected to become completely resolved, for Cod has not promised to remove the possibility of doubt. It is sufficient that we make decisions on the weight of evidence, 9 in confidence that with adequate investigation the weight of evidence will be on the side of Inspiration.


FOOTNOTES

1. Signs Report to the Nation: Adventists and Evolution: "Glorious victory or sad mistake?" Signs of the Times 99 (6):12, 13 (1972).

2. Donald E. Hall, "The 23-hour day," Spectrum 3:39-51 (1971).

3. J. W. Wells, "Coral growth and geochronometry," Nature 797:948-950 (1963).

4. R. R. Newton, "Secular accelerations of the earth and moon," Science 766:825-831 (1969).

5. G. Pannella, "Paleontological evidence on the earth's rotational history since early Precambrian," Astrophysics and Space Sci. 16:212-237 (1972).

6. G. E. Farrow, "Periodicity structures in the bivalve shell: experiments to establish growth controls in Cerastoderma edule from the Thames estuary, Paleontology 74:571-588 (1971).

7. C. T. Scrutton, and R. G. Hipkin, "Longterm changes in the rotation rate of the earth," Earth-Science Rev. 9:259-274 (1973).

8. H. W. Clark, Genesis and Science (Southern Publishing Asso., Nashville, Tenn., 1967), pp. 76-80.

9. Ellen G. White, Messages to Young People, 1948, p. 190.

Advertisement - RevivalandReformation 300x250

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-assistant professor of biology, Graduate School, Loma Linda University at the time this article was written

September 1974

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

"Take Heed to the Ministry"

DR. RICHARD HAMMILL'S concluding challenge in his expository study of Colossians at the recent Bible Conference conducted at Pacific Union College is especially directed toward the ministry of this church. His appeal centered around Paul's words recorded in verse 17 of the last chapter of this Epistle. . .

A Time of Dividing Ahead

FELLOW LEADERS, a time of shaking is just ahead! The Word of God foretells it. The Lord's last-day messenger confirms it. The experience will be a traumatic one indeed, for we will see some shaken out of this message in whom we had great confidence. There will be others whom we felt were weak in faith who will stand like rocks. You and I as leaders in His church need to be prepared for the days ahead. . .

Well-planned Witnessing

It seems strange that this plan of territorial assignment breaks down at the local church level the very area where great efficiency is needed if "every creature" is to hear the message. We are faced with a situation at the local church level similar to what we might expect in a local conference if the president failed to as sign specific territorial responsibility to the ministers. . .

The Adventist Emphasis

A REALISTIC look at the billions of human population in the world today may prove somewhat dis heartening to anyone who believes that Seventh-day Adventists have a message to give to the world. Christianity as a whole is losing rather than gaining dominance among world religions (numerically speaking), and Seventh-day Adventists must be reckoned but a "drop in the bucket" among Christians as a whole. . .

"How Long, O God?"

THE monumental pillar upon which an atheist hangs his doubts is the existence of evil. If there is a good God, why doesn't He do something about the tragedies of existence? Why is He indifferent to sorrow, pain, war, poverty, and the like?

The Cross in the 2300 Days

AS A CHURCH we take proper pride in the fact that Christ is the glorious center of every doctrine and tenet of our faith. We dare not preach any message unless it bears in visible prominence the impress of the cross. The power of Paul's ministry derived from his constant exaltation of the cross. . .

Target 80--The Bold Adventure

TARGET 80 involves the application of modern management principles to church growth and strategy. It has really captured the imagination of our administrators and departmental leaders throughout the Far Eastern Division. We have already begun to see a strong upward turn since launching this eight-year evangelistic thrust. Many areas have had more baptisms this year than for the same period in 1973. . .

The Return of the Jews

TODAY the state of Israel exists as a nation in Palestine, and approximately one sixth of the world's Jewish population reside there as citizens of the country. The establishment of the Jewish state of Israel has become a fact of modern history. . .

Adventist Mission: After a Hundred Years

AFTER a hundred years of over seas mission the Adventist Church has grown from a small community of about 6,000 believers in 1874 to a worldwide movement of nearly 2.4 million believers to day; from an exclusively America-based group to a universal church, 80 percent of whose members now live outside North America. And, if the present differences in the annual growth rates continue, ten years from now approximately 85 percent of the Adventist world membership will be found in countries outside North America. . .

The Challenge of a Total Commitment

A FEW months ago I made a startling discovery. For the first time since just after my baptism some twenty-six years ago, I really wanted the Lord to return. Not at some later date but right then, preferably that same day. . .

Above All Things

SENSING a need for a more personal contact with people, and alarmed by the news released by the U.S. Health Department that 25 million Americans suffer from hypertension and are not even aware of it, the Florida Conference has developed several Adventist Community Services centers and eighteen Mobile Screening Units. . .

Simple Home Remedies

There are few medical emergencies that can rival a burn in production of pain, potential complications, and disability. Burns may be thermal (produced by heat), chemical, or electrical in origin; there is little practical difference in either sequelae or in treatment. They are classified in severity as first, second, and third degree. . .

Protein--That Vital Ingredient (Part 1)

FOR MANY people protein has taken on special, almost magic qualities. They have been told it can be counted on as a body builder and also a body slimmer! Because of some popular reducing diets, the notion seems to be widespread that protein either does not contain any calories or it "burns up fat" in some marvelous way!

Charismatic Countdown

A professional man in your church comes to you and says he has been attending meetings of a charismatic group. He likes the warmth of the fellowship and wonders why Adventists, who emphasize the gift of prophecy, are strangely silent on tongues. If we have been blessed by one gift would we not be doubly blessed by two?

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Trending

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)