Reviewed by Jack J. Blanco, Department of Religion, Southern College, Collegedale, Tennessee.

This little volume should be on the reading list of anyone committed to the divine authority of Scripture. Though written for seminarians, it is easy to read. Its subtitle, The History of Interpretation in the Light of Current Issues, introduces the reader to the challenge to scriptural authority the church faces from the disciplines of philosophy, literary criticism, linguistics, history, science, and theology.

In the chapter on obstacles, Silva delineates some of the difficulties we find in accepting scriptural authority:

1. The Bible is divine, yet it has come to us in human form.

2. We are dependent only on the Holy Spirit for instruction, yet scholar ship is surely necessary.

3. The Scriptures seem to presuppose a literal and historical reading, yet we are also confronted by the figurative and non-historical.

4. Proper interpretation requires personal freedom, yet some degree of external, corporate (church) authority is also needed.

5. The objectivity of the biblical mes sage is essential, yet our presuppositions seem to inject a degree of subjectivity into the interpretive process.

The author discusses these obstacles in their historical setting, promising to take a closer look at them in later volumes of the series he is editing.

As Silva points out, some of these biblical tensions began as early as the second and third centuries after Christ. This was when the church was influenced by the hermeneutics of Philo, the Jewish scholar, and Origen, one of the brightest theological luminaries within the Christian community. Other tensions arose over the authority of Scripture during the Reformation with its emphasis on a more literal reading of the Bible. Later tensions came from the onslaught of rationalism against miracles and the supernatural, and today still more are coming from modern science and literary criticism. These tensions, Silva says, must be addressed if the church wishes to retain a degree of credibility in an age of research.

I wish the author had given a running commentary on the history of biblical interpretation by centuries, rather than grouping his content into topics forcing him to repeat the effect of Origen and others on each problem area. But Silva does give an objective view of the overall problem of biblical interpretation and a brief, balanced view of its history.

When perusing this volume, the reader is impressed with the realization that scriptural authority has always been at the center of controversies throughout the history of the church. Anyone wishing more knowledge about the challenge now confronting the church, especially in the context of Christ's second coming, will find this book well worth reading.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
Reviewed by Jack J. Blanco, Department of Religion, Southern College, Collegedale, Tennessee.

February 1989

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Harvest 90 victory

A worldwide evangelistic campaign could provide the key to a victorious culmination of Harvest 90.

Did Ellen White support the ordination of women?

If no direct support for ordination of women can be found in Ellen White's writings, can we perhaps find evidence that she supported it in her actions?

It isn't all Yesterday

With a little encouragement, you can start a group that offers your church rich resources of time, money, experience, and commitment.

Vocational stress in Adventist ministers

Adventist ministers face significant stresses because of differences in the way they, their conferences, and their congregations perceive their roles. Second in a three-part series.

Putting the school back in Sabbath school

While, as a pastor or a pastor's spouse, you may not have prepared to teach a Sabbath school class, you often must. Here's how you can hold your class's interest and communicate your material.

Deciding about abortion

We were able to discover a number of areas on which most of us agreed.

Pastor's Pastor: Why Inter-America grows

Pastor's Pastor: Why Inter-America grows

Milk: has the time come?

Milk bacterial counts in Chicago in 1904 ranged from 10,000 to 74 million.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)