Book Review: More than a Prophet

Truth is progressive. This idea is foundational to Adventist epistemology, and ultimately, for a theology of spiritual gifts. More Than a Prophet builds on this concept by arguing that the Adventist denomination needs to grow in its understanding of Ellen White's prophetic life and ministry.

Michael W. Campbell, Ph.D. is pastor of the Montrose and Gunnison Seventh-day Adventist Churches in western Colorado.

Truth is progressive. This idea is foundational to Adventist epistemology, and ultimately, for a theology of spiritual gifts. More Than a Prophet builds on this concept by arguing that the Adventist denomination needs to grow in its understanding of Ellen White’s prophetic life and ministry. The church needs to face up to the real Ellen White. More Than a Prophet is also the third installment by the author since 2004 to help Adventists obtain a clearer understanding of Ellen White and inspiration. Bradford is a recently retired professor of practics. This third book is much broader than either of his two previous books, Prophets Are Human (2004) and People Are Human (2005), in which a fictional dialogue is set up to answer questions that an Adventist couple face—especially those questions raised because of criticisms generated through negative Web sites.

One could have wished that the content of the book was more carefully edited. The publisher, at the very least, should have caught the numerous errors that abound throughout the book. For example, beginning with footnote 188 (p. 115) every footnote is off by one (there is no footnote 443 in the text). Despite this, once one gets past these problems, an even more foundational problem is the view of Ellen White and Adventist history that he presents.

If the church were to accept his view of inspiration and the role and authority of Ellen White, it would certainly mark a real shift in the stance of the church toward her prophetic ministry. It is for this reason and several more that the Ellen White Estate has issued a disclaimer that it does not endorse the book, despite the foreword’s mistaken claim that the manuscript was favorably reviewed by White Estate officers. Other church leaders who had initially endorsed his two earlier books now seem to be distancing themselves from this volume.

So why is the book controversial? The answer lies in his understanding of the relationship between Christianity and culture. These paradigms, which became popular in scholarly circles after the publication of H. Richard Niebuhr’s classic, Christ and Culture (1949), argue for five descriptive categories. These categories run within a continuum. On one side there is the view that Christ is against culture; on the other side is the view that Christ is of culture. Most of the church, Niebuhr suggested, rest somewhere in what he called “the church of the middle.”

While not explicitly stated, the relationship of Ellen White to her culture as presented by Bradford is one that is much closer to the “of” side of the continuum instead of being closer to the “church of the middle.” In developing his views of “culture,” Bradford places the 1919 Bible Conference at a critical juncture between the Ellen White of history and the Ellen White found in the church today. It was at this Conference, he maintains, that the real truth about Ellen White was hidden.

Although these transcripts were discovered in 1973 (thanks to inquiries made by Don Mansell), only a modest amount of study has been given to the transcripts.

Bradford argues that “progressives” like A. G. Daniells and W. W. Prescott, in fighting against traditionalists like J. S. Washburn and Claude Holmes who were advocating the verbal inspiration of the testimonies or Ellen White’s writings, were correct in pointing out historical errors in The Great Controversy and the entire process of how she prepared her books—they knew from firsthand experience that her writings were far from inerrant. Yet Bradford only examines the two discussions about inspiration that occurred at the end of the Conference and does not talk about earlier discussions that prefaced them. If he had, he would probably be uncomfortable with the verbal inspiration of the Bible that some of these “progressives” articulated. Ultimately, both the “progressives” and the “traditionalists” were impacted by the rising fundamentalist movement— especially as a way to combat the rise of modernism, which threatened the inspiration of Scripture. Many Adventists today would be uncomfortable with either position. Was the real truth about Ellen White covered up? Not in the way that Bradford presents it. The Adventist Church was at a pivotal moment in its history when it grappled with how it would face functioning without a living prophet. The fact of the matter is that the church was also confronted with a much broader shift in American culture that would have far-reaching implications for the continued development of Adventist theology. Instead, the 1919 Bible Conference polarized Adventist theology into two camps (in fact, it is the first time that the term liberals and conservatives are utilized in an Adventist meeting). These two camps would fragment and overlap through the rest of the twentieth century and continue to impact the church up to the present.

In conclusion, a central argument for Bradford is that “there has consistently been a group that has a more enlightened understanding of her role but they have not felt free to share what they know with the larger body of believers” (193). Bradford presumes that he is part of this progressive and therefore enlightened group. Unfortunately his view of inspiration and Adventist history that he presents is fatally fl awed. This book therefore does not contribute toward unearthing the real Ellen White and thus represents a step backward for the church in its progressive quest for truth.

Advertisement - Ministry in Motion 300x250

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
Michael W. Campbell, Ph.D. is pastor of the Montrose and Gunnison Seventh-day Adventist Churches in western Colorado.

February 2007

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Sinners in the hands of God

Many earnest Christians have expressed sincere concern over the fairness of God in His executions of retributive justice in hell. Of course, Seventh-day Adventists have been in the forefront of the opposition to the interpretation of hell that teaches an eternity of conscious, endless physical, mental, and emotional torture for the lost.

Descending into administration

Let me be honest. For years, somewhere in the crevices of my heart, lay buried a secret desire to be a leader, to try my hand at church administration- perhaps because of the high pedestal on which I pictured leadership, or maybe I just wanted the challenge of leading and influencing the future in a larger setting than the local church.

Being the message

Pigeons have been carrying messages of peace and hope since the day the dove brought the olive leaf back to Noah. In ancient European history, they were seen as saviors during a siege.

Pastoral care during life passages

Because church members do not routinely ask their pastors directly for pastoral care, ministers need to be creative in order to give that care to them. One way to do this would be to listen to their life experiences during crucial times, especially during life passages such as births, adoptions, birthdays, weddings, baptisms, anniversaries, graduations, retirements, and funerals. Such occasions are windows of opportunity for pastoral care.

Blogging: a new way to share your faith

What is blogging? Today, another revolution, called blogging, has surfaced. Blogging offers endless possibilities for sharing your faith almost instantly to millions around the globe. Blogging is all about connections-using the magic of Internet.

Listening to your listeners

Many preachers view preaching as simply a time to speak. They fail to recognize that effective preachers need to listen attentively to their listeners. Every listener provides valuable feedback during the sermon, and wise preachers will learn to listen attentively to this feedback in order to connect more effectively with their congregation.

The final push

It was Martin's first marathon, and he had trained hard. But now the crisis had hit. As I stopped the car and looked at him coming up at a snail's pace, I knew he was in trouble. I started downhill to run with him on the final leg. "Come on, you've come this far, you've done a great job-you can do it!" Slowly but surely, we climbed that hill together. "Look at the top. After this only the stadium and no more hills. The end is in sight. Come on, don't give up now!"

Faith and science: a personal story

As a scientist, I do research in the area of radiometric dating and the directly associated earth science concepts of plate tectonics2 and magma cooling rates.3 I am also a person of faith and a strong believer in the importance of Genesis 1-11, but I work daily with data that I don't know how to fit into a short time frame. I would like to find convincing evidence confirming the literalness of the Genesis record, but in my area of research I usually find that the data fits better with a long-age model. Nevertheless, though I may appear to some to bow to the god of evolution in my research, just as Naaman told Elisha, I also declare, "[Y]our servant will not offer burnt offering or sacrifice to any god but the Lord."

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Trending

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - Digital Discipleship (160x600)