* Pastor C. G. Tuland has had many years of experience in denominational work in a number of mission lands: Europe, the Near East, and South America. Much of his time has been spent in administrative work. At present he is the pastor of the Seventh-day Adventist German church in Chicap, Illinois, where he is working on his dissertation for his doctorate in Semitic Languages and Old Testament at the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago.

The ability to foretell future events was to many Old Testa­ment prophets an endorsement of their divine commission. As a supernatural phenomenon it was also a strong evidence for the claims of Israel's God to be the only and true God of the uni­verse. Modern scholars have been at issue with those who accept the Bible as a divine revela­tion. They deny the reality of predictive proph­ecy in the sense that Seventh-day Adventists have believed it. The position of these scholars emanates from the idea that there is no such thing as divine revelation, and that so-called prophecies can be easily explained in natural historical terms. They endeavor to humanize all manifestations of the prophetic gift exactly as they try to eliminate the supernatural from the Old and New Testament.

This idea is expressed by Pfeiffer in his In­troduction to the Old Testament, page 755.

There he states concerning prophecies that they "lie outside the realm of historical facts." He recognizes that "the correct . . . prediction of history belongs to the realm of the supernatu­ral" but also asserts that "historical research can deal only with authenticated facts which are within the sphere of natural possibilities."

This concept of Biblical criticism also ex­plains the tendency of many scholars during the past century to lower the dates of numerous Old Testament writings, thereby automatically placing the date of the prophecies after the prophesied events had already taken place. C. C. Torrey's radical attitude in this matter often led him to extremes in dating certain books of the Old Testament. "By far the greater part of this [prophetic] literature," he says, "was produced after the extinction of the He­brew kingdom, and we are gradually becoming aware of the fact that the time of greatest pro­duction was in the late Persian and early Greek periods."—The Second Isaiah, p. 85.

In view of the denial of a supernatural reve­lation bolstered by an alleged historical sup­port resulting from establishing low dates of certain Biblical writings, one cannot be too astonished at the erroneous conclusions found in certain textbooks that have appeared during the past century. As early as 1833 F. Hitzig wrote, "The Messianic interpretation is alto­gether contrary to the character of prophecy, which excludes prediction."—Der Prophet Je­saja (Heidelberg), quoted in Christoffer North, The Suffering Servant, p. 30. C. C. Torrey's explanation as to why, in his opinion, predic­tion is excluded is stated thus:

The true prophet must be a clairvoyant and an infallible oracle. These notions—and their modern perpetuation—belong properly to the sphere of folk-lore, and the oft-cited passages quoted above have no significance whatever for the actual history of the great line of Israel's teachers.—The Second Isaiah, pp. 87, 88.

As long as Old Testament criticism succeeded in maintaining its untenable position of the late origin of prophetic books, prophecy, in many instances, could not be established as be­ing fulfilled in history. Frantically, some scholars clung to their theories as is illustrated by the strange conclusion of Sh. Spiegel, which con­tradicts sound reasoning. On the assumption that there is no such thing as predictive proph­ecy, his argument, in effect, is that if "prophe­cies" are fulfilled, they are proved not to have been prophecies but merely a later addition or change of the text, and that if some utterance is not fulfilled, it is to be accepted as a true prophecy, being written before the event. This is what he says:

Since the prophecy did not come true, it is a genuine prophecy, spoken undoubtedly before the events, and not thereafter retouched to suit them.— Sit. SPIEGEL, Noah, Daniel and Job, pp. 321, 322, in Ginzberg Jubilee Volume.

Some scholars, of course, have been aware of the weakness of their position. The very day Old Testament critics were obliged to accept an earlier or traditional date for the prophetic writings, the arguments against predictive prophecies became invalid. Our ministry should be aware of the impact of archeology upon Old Testament study and the consequent tendency of Old Testament scholars toward a more con­servative attitude toward the Bible. This trend can be found in the writings of William F. Albright, Recent Discoveries in Bible Lands, The Biblical Period, The Bible After Twenty Years of Archeology, and more recently in the paperback edition of From Stone Age to Chris­tianity.

All recent discoveries in the field of Biblical archeology have weakened the position of mod­ernism to the same extent as they have strength­ened traditional data of the Bible. Professor Albright, in his introduction to the last-men­tioned book, summarizes some of the changes that new and astounding discoveries have brought about in the field of Biblical studies. Every student of the Bible will find Professor Albright's introduction, and especially pages 17 to 19, very worth-while reading.

In his introductory comments on prophecy and prophets Albright makes some striking statements that are indeed significant admis­sions from the mouth of one of the foremost scholars in Biblical archeology in our time.

That the prophets were not only dedicated men, but also predictors of the future, is fully recognized in Biblical tradition but has been under-empha­sized by modern Biblical scholars, including my­self in 1940-46. Since then I have seen my error and I now stress the predictive element again, though perhaps from rather novel points of view.—From Stone Age to Christianity, p. 17.

Albright goes on to say, "It is wholly unnec­essary to reckon with 'prophecies after the event': we have exceedingly few cases of vati­cinium ex eventu in the Hebrew Bible before the third or second century, 13.C."—Ibid., p. 18. While he does defend the prophets even in cases where their prophecies did not come to pass, Albright apparently is still anxious to maintain the underlying contention of modern scholars that the explanation of the phenome­non of prophecy is through natural causes. He in part attributes it to "the capacity for intui­tive grasp of wide fields of perception which has characterized certain figures of the last 250 years, at least in occasional moments of exalta­tion."—Ibid., p. 19. There are, however, as we know, hundreds of prophecies written in the Bible that have been fulfilled throughout his­tory, and that are far too remarkable to be ex­plained on the basis of human intuitiveness.

The observations of Professor Albright have still another aspect for this denomination. In referring to prophetic insight in more recent times, he says: "We need to refer only to the famous prophecies of the future of Germany and France by Heinrich Heine and Leon Bloy, or to the fantastic previsions of future technol­ogy by Jules Verne, or to the glimpses into the future on the part of Emanuel Swedenborg and Ellen White."—Ibid., p. 19. Modern man's archeological rediscovery of the trustworthiness of the Bible has thus resulted in a more ortho­dox and realistic recognition of Biblical proph­ecy. Mr. Albright's admission that the Bible does indeed contain true predictive prophecy and his recognition of the genuine predictive element in the writings of Ellen G. White are of special significance, coming as they do from one of the foremost Biblical scholars and archeologists of our time.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

* Pastor C. G. Tuland has had many years of experience in denominational work in a number of mission lands: Europe, the Near East, and South America. Much of his time has been spent in administrative work. At present he is the pastor of the Seventh-day Adventist German church in Chicap, Illinois, where he is working on his dissertation for his doctorate in Semitic Languages and Old Testament at the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago.

November 1957

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

To Our Pastors—Our Unsung Heroes

A special note of thanks to our faithful pastors around the world.

The Church Pastor

Why a true church pastor is a gift from the Lord.

Qualities of Christian Scholarship

In giving consideration briefly to Christian scholar­ship, the selection of certain basic qualities by which a scholar might be identified would seem to be of value.

Public Relations on Church and Community Level

Because public relations as such is a relatively new innovation within the church, eyebrows have been raised and the prospects of change have been by some viewed with alarm. But it can be effectively used in the cause of Christ.

"He Maketh a Path to Shine After Him"

Do we exert a negative or positive influence?

Community Relations Army Style

The US Army lays a heavy stress on the importance of good community relations. What about the church? Shouldn't we do the same?

Pastoral Counseling--Some Common Criticisms

An exploration of some common criticism against pastoral counseling.

The Pastor's Throne

The most sacred spot in the world is the pulpit.

Thou Shalt Covet

We need to covet earnestly the best gifts of the Spirit.

Reviving the Delight of Reading

Encouraging reading in the SDA household is paramount and crucial.

The New Bible Instructor

How to transition well and avoid being overburdened by the work.

Fostering Local Church Departments

The pastor must learn to manage the various responsibilities and departments of church work.

Pointer's to Progress

Monthly pulpit pointer's by the Ministry staff.

Gratitude and Thanksgiving

Counsel from the Spirit of Prophecy

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)