When Is a Person Ready for Baptism?

NEARLY every ordained minister has been questioned by his conscience if not by his members because someone he baptized has apostatized. Why did he leave the church? Did I baptize him too quickly? Did I fail to explain the doctrines of the church? Did I bring him to the foot of the cross?

-Pastor of the Grand Junction, Colorado, SDA church, at the time this article was written

NEARLY every ordained minister has been questioned by his conscience if not by his members because someone he baptized has apostatized. Why did he leave the church? Did I baptize him too quickly? Did I fail to explain the doctrines of the church? Did I bring him to the foot of the cross?

I have known of some serious splits in congregations because of the falling away of new believers. Some maintained that the minister was at fault because he "hurried them into the tank." Others contended that the congregation never accepted them whole-heartedly into their fellowship. Still others believed that the weakness lay with the new believers themselves.

We cannot deny that on some occasions the eagerness to maintain or increase membership has led some ministers to bring to the baptismal tank some candidates who were unprepared for church membership. The lack of preparation may be a result of insufficient instruction, or it may be owing to the youthfulness of the candidate. Some candidates are not thoroughly convinced of the "testing truths"; others the children may be too young to know what it is all about.

Discovering when a person is ready for baptism is somewhat like trying to discover the right time to be married or to buy a house. Although there may be several "right times," there is also a time that is too soon.

Is giving one's heart to Christ sufficient preparation for baptism? Is baptism the only prerequisite for church membership? Can a person be saved without being baptized, or can he be saved without becoming a member of a church? Apparently "salvation," "baptism," and "church member ship" occupy some common ground, but what is it? Certainly we cannot answer the question "When is a person ready for baptism?" until we have thoroughly understood the relationship be tween baptism, salvation, and church membership.

"Baptism" and "salvation" are not interchangeable. They are not synonymous. But they are a part of a whole, of which "church membership" is also a part. The Seventh-day Adventist Church makes baptism a prerequisite to church membership (with certain special exceptions). The Bible so instructs. But this ordinance was never intended to produce a miraculous change in the life of the new candidate, as some people seem to expect.

Baptism should be one of the outward results of a transformation that has already begun to take place in the life. Nor should it ever be entered into with the expectancy that it will produce, through some kind of sanctified magic, a lifelong conformation to a code of moral or behavioral rules. Even conversion without renewal does not guarantee such a lifelong allegiance to God's wishes.

Neither should baptism be looked upon as the main requirement for church membership. As the doorway to the fold of God, this sacred rite should be thought of as the last of many steps leading from a life of rebellion to a life of obedience.

Perhaps the confusion as to the real intent of true baptism is one of the church's greatest problems today. Baptism should be ad ministered to a candidate by a minister only when both clearly understand the true significance of the ordinance. If ministers or laymen ignore the clear-cut Bible provision for the real intent of baptism, then we do ourselves and our cause a real disservice.

Conversion to Precede Baptism

All who desire to be saved are to receive the benefits and blessings of conversion and baptism. Neither true heart conversion nor baptism is to be ignored, by passed, or minimized. Neither is to replace the other, and the order must never be reversed. True heart conversion should always precede baptism. Salvation begins, not at baptism, but at conversion. It is the duty of the minister to detect and evaluate the depth of a candidate's commitment to Christ his conversion to the best of his ability.

Salvation does not consist of the act of joining a church! It does not even consist of a formal attachment to the remnant church, as much as we might like to think it does. Neither does salvation necessarily occur when there is mental assent to a set of doctrines or beliefs. It is not even saying, "I believe in Jesus," after one has been pressured into doing so to "get someone off his back." Salvation begins with a genuine acceptance of Christ and proceeds by means of His truth and power.

Sometimes we feel that a candidate has been prepared if he has been talked into quitting some evil habit or removing some objectionable items of attire. Such acts of self-denial may take place in the process, but they are not of themselves an indication that the candidate is prepared for baptism. For a candidate to be truly and thoroughly prepared for baptism he must have a living union with Jesus Christ. He must be renewed in heart.

The counsel of the messenger of the Lord is "Salvation is not to be baptized, not to have our names upon the church books, not to preach the truth. But it is a living union with Jesus Christ to be renewed in heart, doing the works of Christ in faith and labor of love, in patience, meekness, and hope." Evangelism, p. 319. "Connection with a church does not take the place of conversion. To subscribe the name to a church creed is not of the least value to anyone if the heart is not truly changed." Ibid., pp. 290, 291. (Italics supplied.)

Jesus Must Be Real

Being fit for church membership involves a personal meeting with the Saviour of mankind. Jesus must be real and obvious in the life. His influence cannot be unidentifiable, hidden, or secret. If He is in the life the new experience will be shared in some way with everyone we meet.

Neither clergy nor laity are to establish qualifications for church membership that God has not ordained. Church membership represents entrance into the family of God and is administered by human beings. It is a privilege and a responsibility that has been granted by God through His representative body here on earth to those and to those alone whose lives have given evidence of being changed by the indwelling Spirit. If this change is not evident, then an individual should not be granted membership or retained in the body of Christ.

It is our responsibility to lead the seeking individual to the foot of the cross of Jesus Christ, our wonderful Lord. Here the sinner is to surrender in total submission and entire obedience to the claims of Christ his Saviour, with whom he has become personally acquainted. He is to confess his sins to God. He then enters the kingdom of God. There follows a period of time in which the fruitage of conversion begins to be seen in his life. Once this fruitage appears, through his knowledge of the truth and empowerment of the Holy Spirit, he is ready for baptism, and it should be ad ministered without undue delay. Baptism by immersion is the declaration that the new life in Christ Jesus has begun. It is a testimony to the world that Christ now lives within.

Must Be Individually Determined

Baptism is an acknowledgment of an already-changed life. It is an outward sign confirming that something has happened inside. Sometimes this change can take place rather hurriedly, so the time from acceptance until baptism must be determined in each individual case. It is an individual experience. To push a person into baptism is a mistake. To lead him into it is success. If we try to move ahead of the Holy Spirit's leading we are doomed to failure and will be baptizing people who are not ready for baptism. But when we are moving with the Holy Spirit we will establish a true member in God's family. Ministers must be living close to God every day to know when they are moving with the Holy Spirit.

Not all conversions are alike. One has no right to judge the quality of another's conversion or lack of it by his own, nor do the two have to take the same or even similar pathways. But conversion, taking place when it may and in the way it chooses, must be experienced before the rite of baptism.

Sometimes a person is baptized prematurely. This is unfortunate. One way to avoid making such a mistake is not to do anything. In some matters this course might be appropriate, but not here. We can make a dreadful mistake if we fail to baptize a person when the proper time has arrived. I have often said, especially when considering those who may be young in years, that I would much rather baptize a person twice than not baptize him at all. "When they give evidence that they fully understand their position, they are to be accepted." Testimonies to Ministers, p. 128.

Many times people are urged to put off this important step, but the messenger of the Lord says: "There is one thing that we have no right to do, and that is to judge another man's heart or impugn his motives. But when a person presents himself as a candidate for church membership, we are to examine the fruit of his life, and leave the responsibility of his motive with himself." --Evangelism, p. 313.

May God help us not to stand in the way of souls who want to enter in and also to make sure that those we baptize have demonstrated genuine conversion as evidenced by the fruit of the Spirit in their lives.


Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus
-Pastor of the Grand Junction, Colorado, SDA church, at the time this article was written

October 1973

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Church Management

WHEN YOU have a great mission, approach the attainment of it consciously and skillfully and do not leave success to chance. . .

Women's "Distinctive Duties"

Does lack of or little representation on the highest councils, along with the Biblical admonition given to women to submit to their husbands, constitute an admission that the woman is subservient to man? Is man really pre-eminent? Not at all. . .

Ecumenism--The Old and the New

HAS THE ecumenical movement gone as far as it can? Or is the present lull merely a rest period before another surge toward Christian unity?

Baptism for the Dead--A New Look at an Old Problem

THE TOMB was no longer a one-way street. The grave was no longer a dead-end road. The resurrection of Christ was breaking the way into a new life. Now there was a way out, a way of escape to life. Incomprehensible? Yes. Unbelievable? No.

Impact For God

"I RECOGNIZE your voice," blurted out a strange woman in a restaurant here in Greensboro, North Carolina. She then recalled having seen me on television and asked me to come by some time and answer some questions for her. I began giving Peggy, for that was her name, and her family Bible studies. After they had attended church for several months we began a series of evangelistic meetings. The whole family accepted God's truth and became members of the remnant church. Peggy speaks convincingly when she says, "I know the Lord led you to me that day."

Is Baptism More Than a Symbol?

IN GALATIANS 3:27 (R.S.V.),* Paul emphasizes the point that "as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ." Baptism, then, implies a union with Christ Himself. . .

Health Education in Ethiopia

HEALTH EDUCATION as such is a fairly new field. We as a church, however, have always believed in health education from the earliest beginnings of "health reform" until a more complete plan of health education was incorporated into the sanitarium philosophy of operating health institutions. . .

"Who, Me? . . . Become a Vegetarian?"

WHEN we became Seventh-day Adventists we soon realized that Adventists taught, although not all practiced, some rather unique health principles. Gradually we began to accept and practice many of these, but it was not until I became a student at the Loma Linda University School of Health that I really began to understand the scientific and Biblical backgrounds for these health practices. Prior to this, Adventists told me, "Oh, this isn't good for you" or "It's all right to eat this." But nowhere had I heard an explanation of why it was or wasn't good that really satisfied me. . .

From Battle Creek to Battles Now

SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS have a long-standing interest and imperative in medicine as an expression and tool of religious thought and action. The ideals, purposes, and practices of religion in medicine and medicine in religious life have long been a part of our history. Today we find in all religious bodies a renewed, expanded, and vigorous resurgence of interest and demand for religionists and medical practitioners to unite in meeting the dilemma of the whole man as he faces future shock. . .

Man's Allotted Span

BY THE TIME this message gets into print the writer will have arrived at that age which the psalmist said is "man's allotted span," three score years and ten, and I thought I ought to write and tell you about it, for the experience is new to me. If you are like most of us you will have to be reminded of the occasion by your wife, your secretary, your daughter who bought you a necktie, or a son who bought you after-shave lotion. Actually, it doesn't hurt— there is no crossing a sound barrier, no sonic boom, no bells ring, no whistles blow—you just wake up and there you are. In fact, you are glad you did wake up and are there, for the alternative seems to be so final. . .

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up

Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - SermonView - WideSkyscraper (160x600)