Non-Biblical Testimony to the Historicity of Jesus

Non-Biblical Testimony to the Historicity of Jesus*

There is no person in all the annals of history in behalf of whom there is more convincing testimony than for Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ of the New Testament.

BY  W. W. Prescott

There is no person in all the annals of history in behalf of whom there is more convincing testimony than for Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ of the New Testament. To some who have not given the matter serious attention, this statement may seem unwarranted; but certain facts must not be overlooked in deciding this question.

The testimony of contemporaries is of prime value. The men who wrote the four Gospels were associates of Jesus. Day by day they saw the mul­titudes who assembled wherever He went; they heard His wonderful teach­ing; they saw His works; and they testified in the most artless way of what they themselves had seen and heard.

Not only so, but through all the cen­turies of the Christian era millions upon millions have borne witness to the reality of the now invisible Christ. The history of the Christian church is itself unimpeachable proof of the fact of Christ.

It is true that there are some shal­low thinkers with an impulse to create sensation and to secure a transitory notoriety, who will claim to doubt the historical reality of Jesus of Nazareth, but they are not worthy of serious attention. Generally speaking, even those who deny the truth of His unique claims, do yet admit that such a person actually lived in the early part of the first century.

"It is too late in the day for any intelligent student of history to deny or even to question the historicity of Jesus. Equally impossible is it to doubt that the four Gospels present a substantially accurate and faithful ac­count of His person and work. Unless these Gospels are all second-century compilations of traditions which have passed through many mouths and been both colored and enlarged in the pass­ing; unless they contain incidents which never occurred, but were only imagined, and speeches that were never spoken but only invented; and unless it be an a priori assumption that miracle is impossible and every narrative reporting miracle is a fiction, it must be admitted that no reasonable ground exists for challenging the truth­fulness of the portrait of Jesus which has been drawn by the evangelists."— "Jehovah-Jesus," Rev. Thomas White-law, D. D., p. 9.

But there are some who accept the testimony of the four Gospels, and yet ask in a good spirit whether there are other writers of those early times who confirm the historicity of the Man of Nazareth. For the benefit of this class of inquirers, and of any others who may be interested in the subject, the following results of- our investigation are herewith submitted.

Josephus, the Jewish historian, whose works are so well known, would naturally hesitate to give prominence to one whose claims were rejected by his nation, and who so severely rebuked its religious leaders, and yet he does bear testimony to the fact of Christ. Here is one quotation from his writings:

"Now there was about this time Jesus, a wise man; if it be lawful to call Him a man; for He was a doer of wonderful works, and a teacher of such men as receive the truth with pleasure. He drew over to Him both many of the Jews and many of the Gentiles. He was the Christ. And when Pilate, at the suggestion of the principal men among us, had con­demned Him to the cross, those that loved Him at the first did not forsake Him; for He appeared to them alive again, the third day: as the divine prophets had foretold these and ten thousand other wonderful things con­cerning Him. And the tribe of Chris­tians, so named from Him, is not ex­tinct at this day."—"Antiquities of the Jews," book 18, chap. 3. Translated by Whiston.*

Another extract from Josephus, which, so far as we know, has not been questioned, reads thus: 

"Festus was now dead, and Albinus [the procurator of Judea] was but upon the road. So he [Ananus the on the road. So he [Ananus the high priest] assembled the Sanhedrin of judges, and brought before thein the brother of Jesus who.was called Christ, whose name was James, and some of his companions."--/d., book 20, chap. 9.

A paragraph of some length in the "Annals" of Tacitus deals with the ex­perience of the Christians in the time of Nero. After speaking 'of certain ones whom "the common.people called Christians,".Tacitus affirmed:. "Auctor nominis' ejus Christus, Tiberio imperi­tante, per procuratorem Poritium Pila­turn, supplicio adfectus erat [Christ, the originator of this name, had been punished by the procurator Pontius Pilate in the reign of Tiberius]."--- "Annals." 15, 44.

Those who accepted Christ as the promised Messiah Were called Chris­tians, and Suetonius in his "Life of Nero" mentioned their punishment by Nero in these words: "Afilicti supplicia Christiani, genus hominum super­stitionis nova et malefic [The Chris­tians, a class of men of a new and wicked superstition, were visited with punishments]."---"Vita Neronis" (Life of Nero), par. 16.

Washington, D. C.

(To be concluded) 

* Requests are periodically received at the Association office for dependable informa­tion on this and similar questions requir­ing research and demanding accurate, trust­worthy evidence. In the past, these have for the most part been answered by cor­respondence. But because of their general interest and value many of these will be made available to all.—Editors.

*It is true that- the genuineness of this paragraph has been seriously questioned by some writers, and positively denied by George Rawlinson in a note on a lecture delivered at Oxford in which he declared : "I regard the arguments which have been brought against the famous passage in our conies of Josephus concerning our Lord's life and teaching as having completely established its spuriousness."—The Bamp­ton Lectures, 1859, p. 896. In direct con­trast with this view is the testimony of Thomas Hartwell Horne, the conservative Bible scholar of the last century, who gives good reasons for accepting the paragraph as genuine. Among his reasons for believ­ing that the evidence is most decidedly in favor of the genuineness' of this testimony of Josephus" are the following: "1. It is  found' in all the copies [italics his] of Josephus' works which are now extant, whether printed or manuscript ; in a Hebrew translation preserved in the Vatican library, and in an Arabic version preserved by the Maronites of Mount Libanus. 2. It is cited by Eusebius, Jerome, Rufinus the antagonist of Jerome, Isidore' of Pelusium, Sozomen. Cassiodorus, Nicephorus, and by many other authors. Greeks. Syrians, and Egyptians, of the fourth and fifth centuries; all of whom had indisputably seen various manuscripts, and of considerIble antiquity " --"Horne's Introduction," Vol. 1, p. 511. Such an array of authors in its favor would sPena to justify the acceptanto of the para­graph in question as genuine.

Advertisement - RevivalandReformation 300x250

Ministry reserves the right to approve, disapprove, and delete comments at our discretion and will not be able to respond to inquiries about these comments. Please ensure that your words are respectful, courteous, and relevant.

comments powered by Disqus

BY  W. W. Prescott

February 1932

Download PDF
Ministry Cover

More Articles In This Issue

Called to be Fishers of Men

Men can learn to be fishers of men. None is so poor or unlearned that he cannot become proficient in this divine occupation.

Youthful Recruits Must Augment Our Ministry

With every evidence before us that the world is hastening to its end, and the coming of our Lord is right at hand, how can the claims which we make denominationally be justified in the sight of judgment-bound men, if we do not continually bring into our ministry the vigor, the enterprise, the vision, and the hope of youth—espe­cially at such an hour as this?

Promised Power

I am convinced that our greater success in the ministry is dependent upon our learning to rely upon the promised power disclosed in these words: "Not by might, nor by power, but by My Spirit, saith the Lord of hosts." Zech. 4:6.

Good Counsel as to Unfulfilled Details

Many of us, no doubt, who are con­tinually looking at the prophetic pictures of future events, trying to see more clearly every line of the picture drawn by the inspired pen, often find a detail obscure, when the essential outline stands out plain and clear and positive.

Editorial Keynotes

Cast Not Away Therefore Your Confidence

Personal Work in Connection With Evangelism

In connection with His public ef­forts we find that Jesus was also a personal worker—He worked for in­dividuals.

Holding the Interest

Two great questions press upon us: First, How shall we reach the masses in the large cities? and second, How can we impress them with our message?

A New Experience in Christ

How an ugly dis­position in my home and with my fel­low workers is rapidly being displaced by a new love for everybody and a sweetness of disposition.

Conducting an Effort When Funds Are Low

In these times of depression, our evangelists will feel the curtailment of funds to provide helpers and advertising material.

Sparsely Settled Sections

A minister in these sections ought to hold a cottage meeting or a preach­ing service nearly every night during the week in addition to his visiting and Bible studies during the day.

Attracting Youth to the Bible Work—No. 1

While an apparent overproduction in some departments of our work is receiving serious study, the efficient, all-round, practical Bible worker is still in demand.

The Miraculous Birth of Christ

The assertion was recently hurled at me that Christians worship an illegiti­mate child. Answered by reference to Matthew 1:20, the question was then asked, "Why was it right for the Holy Spirit to do what it was not right for man to do?" How can I best answer this challenge?

Making Stronger Adventists

We have all been distressed to see persons come into the church, apparently in good faith, remain a short time, and then drop out. In my own work I have tried in many ways to remedy this situation. The baptismal class has given some help; but it seems as if we need a more extended course of instruc­tion than the usual class of this kind imparts.

Editorial Postscripts

From the Ministry back page.

View All Issue Contents

Digital delivery

If you're a print subscriber, we'll complement your print copy of Ministry with an electronic version.

Sign up
Advertisement - Southern Adv Univ 180x150 - Animated


Recent issues

See All
Advertisement - NAD Stewardship (160x600)